I'm in a class called healthy lifestyles
and we're talking about healthcare around
the world. I'm 21, I'm under my parents
insurance still since i'm still in college
and was really really naive about this
issue. This class has really opened my
eyes about how much the US healthcare
system SUCKS. We watched most of Michael
Moore's "Sicko" in class..and I dont know
if you've seen it or not but there was one
man who was working and accidently sawed
off the tips of 2 fingers, his middle and
his ring finger. To reattach the middle
finger would cost $60,000 and to attach
the ring finger was 12,000. Given the
financial situation they were in his wife
and he could only have the ring finger
reattached. Basically same story happens
in Great Britain, guy saws off all 4
fingers...goes to the hospital and has all
of them reattached and there is no bill
issued due to their health care policy.
This ridiculous! In London the Doctors are
paid bonuses based on how many patients
they DONT see...meaning their patients
stay healthy, here in the United States,
the more money these doctors save by
denying treatment, the more money the
insurance companies save, so they get a
bonus basically by NOT doing their job!
This is INSANE! All the power is in the
insurance companies and I think thats a
huge problem...I was never worried about
health care(probably since Im under my
parents) but something needs to be done
here.
I was nearly in tears when the woman was
telling her story of how her husband had
cancer. They needed a donor for bone
marrow, found a perfect match in his
little brother and hoped his life could be
saved. Well, turns out their insurance
company considered this proceedure
"experimental" and refused to cover it.
Imagine being in that situation...having a
loved one fight cancer, finding a possible
solution and having your heart ripped out
because you cant afford it and your
insurance wont cover it. I cant imagine
being in this situation
so anyway, i'm done ranting..i just wanna
know how some of you feel about health
care where you're from...and if you're
from the US what do you think needs to be
done here???
|
nightangel73
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005 Posts: 2774 Location: ,
Thanks: 19
Thanked:18
Posted: 09-27-08 12:15pm
That's why I'm voting for Obama!! McCain
won't do anything for this horrible
healthcare situation in america.
|
killbill
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Jan 2008 Posts: 454
Thanks: 43
Thanked:35
Posted: 09-27-08 12:59pm
i'm so glad i live in canada. we don't
have a perfect system but at least we have
something. when i go to the emergency
room or for a check up or when i had my
baby, i never once had to worry about
paying for anything. if my baby is sick,
the doctor will see her the same day and
there is no worry about a bill because
everything's been paid for. we may pay
more taxes than other places, i don't
really know, but i do know that those
taxes pay for our healthcare when we need
it. a person with cancer or some other
life threatening illness shouldn't have to
worry about how they are going to pay so
they can fight for their life. a wealthy
person's life shouldn't be more valuable
than someone who is poor. hospitals
shouldn't be all about profiting off sick
people. i love how micheal moore puts it
in Sicko, if your house was burning down,
you wouldn't hesitate to call 911 because
you know the firemen are there to help
you. they won't show up and hand you a
bill for putting the fire out. why isn't
healthcare just as important?
|
Birch
Moderator
Joined: 07 Nov 2005 Posts: 4159 Location: Bliss,
Thanks: 159
Thanked:16
Posted: 09-27-08 14:49pm
My "health insurance" right now consists
of two things: 1. I save up money to pay
out of pocket for check ups. 2. I go to
the ER at our large metropolitan teaching
hospital that has a system in place of
charging you based on your income.
Right now I have a gaping hole in a wisdom
tooth that broke early this summer. The
crappy health insurance I was on would
only pay for tooth removal if there was an
accident that occurred that caused the
damage, and then only 60%. I asked the
insurance agent over the phone if she were
a dentist (because she was asking me the
circumstances of how my tooth broke) and
when she said no I hung up.
I have a new job lined up and they utilize
something called health insurance savings
account. I am not really up and up on the
details, but it sounds like I put money in
an account every pay period, which can
then be used towards any service. When I
get up to $2000 in bills (which would have
to be paid out of pocket) only then can I
use the savings account. After some point
(not sure, sorry) then the insurance
saving company pays 80% of costs and I pay
20%. Of course, that would all have to be
approved by them. Viagra for men is
covered, birth control for women is not.
There is more money in making sure people
don't receive treatment than making sure
they do.
I hope things get changed. I can't
imagine having a family and kids and
worrying about all this.
|
nightangel73
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005 Posts: 2774 Location: ,
Thanks: 19
Thanked:18
Posted: 09-27-08 22:01pm
Yes killbill you are lucky. And I wish it
was like that in america. I wouldn't mind
paying more taxes to get this benefit.
Right now well I don't have health
insurance issues because I work in a
company with medical benefits but it
frightens me the thought of loosing my job
and then getting sick and then what I will
do.
|
worrywart01
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 15 May 2008 Posts: 811 Location: ,
Thanks: 66
Thanked:11
Posted: 09-29-08 01:03am
nightangel73
wrote:
Yes killbill you are lucky.
And I wish it was like that in america. I
wouldn't mind paying more taxes to get
this benefit. Right now well I don't have
health insurance issues because I work in
a company with medical benefits but it
frightens me the thought of loosing my job
and then getting sick and then what I will
do.
exactly and thats what sucks....
killbill, I remember the part in the movie
where michael more was talking about the
police and firemen, i liked that part as
well...idk if our society right now would
be ok with increasing taxes for health
benefits such as in canada but something
definitely needs to be done...i think
theres another system, i forget
where...where 15 or 20% of what you make
comes out of your paycheck and goes
towards healthcare, obviously if you make
more you're gonna have to donate more..but
I think thats a pretty fair system
I cannot believe Viagra is approved but
birth control isn't!!!! thats ridiculous
|
nightangel73
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005 Posts: 2774 Location: ,
Thanks: 19
Thanked:18
Posted: 09-29-08 18:35pm
And think about what we will do after
retirement. Medicare is threathened with
the increasing number of people with
Alzheimer, it's going to wipe them out.
|
Beline
Supporter
Joined: 01 Mar 2008 Posts: 499 Location: , South Africa
Thanks: 131
Thanked:150
Posted: 10-03-08 00:43am
First world countries.. Bliss..
I live in a third world country (whoopee)
where you have to have health insurance or
you’re stuffed. You can only go to a
private hospital if you have health
insurance or if you are stinking rich –
in which case you can afford medical
insurance anyway.
The news papers here are stuffed with
reports of people dying on the floors! of
the hospitals, defenseless senior citizen
being raped in their hospital beds, and
recently there was an article in a
magazine of a lady who dropped her elderly
mother of at a state hospital because she
had a migraine and now she’s paralyzed
for life. Yip, head hurts, spine damaged.
Medical insurance for me and one dependant
– R 3100.00 per month and I earn R120
000.00 per year. (premiums are not
calculated by income) Entry level
positions (skilled) pays about R4000.00
– R6000.00 per month. Most unskilled
workers only earn R 900.00 per month, and
they are the ones who live in shacks with
no running water – forget about sanitary
systems.
DO NOT COMPLAIN!
|
sillyakchick
Moderator
Joined: 12 Apr 2007 Posts: 2712
Thanks: 8
Thanked:1
Posted: 10-11-08 14:28pm
Beline, I am touched by your stories.
They are truly awful. But you cannot ask
people who see obvious criminal activity
occuring under the guise of a system
originally designed to help people not to
complain about it. The higher ups of
insurance companies are
multi-millionaires. Even someof us who
could pay for basic menial coverage often
find themselves denied that because once
in 1992 I had a migraine or my husband had
a normal lumbar MRI and the insurance
company got nervous and denied him
coverage. My sister can't get coverage
for her two asthmatic children if she
leaves her job, and they require routine
medication. I hate the fear that comes
with sickness. When your health is in
jeopardy the first thing that comes to
mind is not "How will I get better?" but
"How will I pay for this?" I think all
people in all countries deserve basic
health care at no charge. Extra stuff
like lap band surgery, cosmetic surgery,
etc is one thing, but basic coverage
should be a basic human right. I guess
that's why we continue to compain.
|
Beline
Supporter
Joined: 01 Mar 2008 Posts: 499 Location: , South Africa
Thanks: 131
Thanked:150
Posted: 10-12-08 12:42pm
Sorry, Sillyakchick.
You’re right. I guess I’m really
worked up about this issue because a
co-worker of my fiancé passed away about
a day or two before this topic was posted.
She died because of a state hospital’s
gross negligence. Everybody deserves
proper medical assistance when they need
it. Not only the super-rich.
|
killbill
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Jan 2008 Posts: 454
Thanks: 43
Thanked:35
Posted: 10-12-08 13:41pm
We have free healthcare here but it's not
perfect. Just recently a friend of my
aunt's had gallbladder surgery. It was a
day surgery so she was released right
away. A couple of days later she had a
really sore stomach so she went to the
urgent care (emergency) and told the
triage nurse what was going on. She could
barely stand up straight because she was
in so much pain. The nurse told her not
to be so melodramatic because it wouldn't
get her seen by a doctor any sooner.
Well, by the time they did see her it was
too late. She died of an infection in her
abdomen the next day. It could have been
treated if she hadn't had to wait for so
long.
Another man who was in a wheelchair with
diabetes recently died in the emergency
room after sitting there for 35 hours.
They just ignored him and he died in his
wheelchair. Another person waiting
reported it to the nurse and to security
but they didn't do anything.
|
worrywart01
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 15 May 2008 Posts: 811 Location: ,
Thanks: 66
Thanked:11
Posted: 10-13-08 02:23am
killbill
wrote:
We have free healthcare here
but it's not perfect. Just recently a
friend of my aunt's had gallbladder
surgery. It was a day surgery so she was
released right away. A couple of days
later she had a really sore stomach so she
went to the urgent care (emergency) and
told the triage nurse what was going on.
She could barely stand up straight because
she was in so much pain. The nurse told
her not to be so melodramatic because it
wouldn't get her seen by a doctor any
sooner. Well, by the time they did see
her it was too late. She died of an
infection in her abdomen the next day. It
could have been treated if she hadn't had
to wait for so long.
Another man who was in a wheelchair with
diabetes recently died in the emergency
room after sitting there for 35 hours.
They just ignored him and he died in his
wheelchair. Another person waiting
reported it to the nurse and to security
but they didn't do
anything.
these stories are horrible! something
needs to be done this is ridiculous
|
diamondsz
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 07 Oct 2005 Posts: 3333 Location: , Candyland-Canada
Thanks: 98
Thanked:159
Posted: 10-13-08 10:14am
Oh I could so rant about this
subject.....
When I was in labour, they told me I
wasn't having contractions, the machine
didnt pick them up, so they sent me home.
Half way home, we drove back and I had Cam
in less than an hour but think about it if
I was at home, baby would have been born
at home and like Killbill I was told I was
exagerating or being melodramatic.
I think our system isn't any better, drs
are overworked and I think we should have
a system more like britain, meaning make
sure people are treated the best so they
dont come back, Educate them!
|
Birch
Moderator
Joined: 07 Nov 2005 Posts: 4159 Location: Bliss,
Thanks: 159
Thanked:16
Posted: 10-13-08 18:37pm
Yup, the key is covering preventative
services, legislating against unhealthy
food like fast food (yes I know that is
extreme), more benefits if you exercise
and don't smoke, more emphasis on healthy
living all around.
But none of that makes anyone any money,
except maybe gyms.
|
worrywart01
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 15 May 2008 Posts: 811 Location: ,
Thanks: 66
Thanked:11
Posted: 10-14-08 01:45am
Birch
wrote:
Yup, the key is covering
preventative services, legislating against
unhealthy food like fast food (yes I know
that is extreme), more benefits if you
exercise and don't smoke, more emphasis on
healthy living all around.
But none of that makes anyone any money,
except maybe
gyms.
sounds like a great plan to me...and it
actually aims at improving peoples
health...as you said, the key is
PREVENTATIVE care...but the thing is, some
people cant afford that and end up going
in for crisis care and running up a
massive medical bill...ugh, i DREAD
getting my own insurance..lucky for my
family my moms job has provided some
decent benefits..not without a nice dent
in the paycheck of course but..what can
you do...i got about a year and a half
left and apparently at 23 i'm kicked off
of the insurance regardless of whether i'm
out of school and have a full time job or
not...
|
Beline
Supporter
Joined: 01 Mar 2008 Posts: 499 Location: , South Africa
Thanks: 131
Thanked:150
Posted: 10-14-08 03:04am
In South Africa we have a numerous medical
aids schemes you can choose from. The best
known one gives you quite a bit of
discount if you go to a specific gym group
(they’re all over the country) on a
regular basis. You get a swipe card which
you swipe when entering the gym and of
course you swipe it again when you leave.
Your discount at the medical insurance
company is calculated by the number of
hours you spend exercising.
I think it’s a great idea. The healthier
people are the less money the insurance
companies have to cough up when you’re
sick.
And of course the clients benefit with the
discount and of course they get the much
needed exercise.
|
Marc209
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 May 2007 Posts: 64
Thanks: 1
Thanked:0
Re: Healthcare Posted: 10-16-08 13:17pm
worrywart01
wrote:
I'm in a class called
healthy lifestyles and we're talking about
healthcare around the world. I'm 21, I'm
under my parents insurance still since i'm
still in college and was really really
naive about this issue. This class has
really opened my eyes about how much the
US healthcare system SUCKS. We watched
most of Michael Moore's "Sicko" in
class..and I dont know if you've seen it
or not but there was one man who was
working and accidently sawed off the tips
of 2 fingers, his middle and his ring
finger. To reattach the middle finger
would cost $60,000 and to attach the ring
finger was 12,000. Given the financial
situation they were in his wife and he
could only have the ring finger
reattached. Basically same story happens
in Great Britain, guy saws off all 4
fingers...goes to the hospital and has all
of them reattached and there is no bill
issued due to their health care policy.
This ridiculous! In London the Doctors are
paid bonuses based on how many patients
they DONT see...meaning their patients
stay healthy, here in the United States,
the more money these doctors save by
denying treatment, the more money the
insurance companies save, so they get a
bonus basically by NOT doing their job!
This is INSANE! All the power is in the
insurance companies and I think thats a
huge problem...I was never worried about
health care(probably since Im under my
parents) but something needs to be done
here.
I was nearly in tears when the woman was
telling her story of how her husband had
cancer. They needed a donor for bone
marrow, found a perfect match in his
little brother and hoped his life could be
saved. Well, turns out their insurance
company considered this proceedure
"experimental" and refused to cover it.
Imagine being in that situation...having a
loved one fight cancer, finding a possible
solution and having your heart ripped out
because you cant afford it and your
insurance wont cover it. I cant imagine
being in this situation
so anyway, i'm done ranting..i just wanna
know how some of you feel about health
care where you're from...and if you're
from the US what do you think needs to be
done here???
Christ...they are showing Michael Moore
movies in class? I can't believe what some
of these nutty far-left professors will
stoop to. Michael Moore preys on the weak
minded to further his nonsense. He's been
doing it for almost 20 years now.
No....Universal health care does not work
and it's because of what KillBill said -
the delays. You will wait for
everything...Just had a heart attack? Sry,
you'll have to wait for treatment. Had
stroke? Have to wait. Oh, you have cancer,
do you? Gonna have to wait months for
treatment while that sucker spreads.
As far as healthcare in England is
concerned. If people are so satisfied with
their universal health care there, then
why does privatiezed health care keep
growing at an alarming rate?
And Cuba? There's no denying cuba's life
expectancy (which is still lower than the
U.S.), but to survey the people of a
communist nation, where thoughts are
controlled, are a bad idea. And indicatior
is the hundreds of Cuban doctors that keep
migrating to the U.S.
Come on, man. You are 21, do some research
on your own!
|
killbill
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Jan 2008 Posts: 454
Thanks: 43
Thanked:35
Re: Healthcare Posted: 10-16-08 14:10pm
Marc209
wrote:
worrywart01
wrote:
I'm in a class called
healthy lifestyles and we're talking about
healthcare around the world. I'm 21, I'm
under my parents insurance still since i'm
still in college and was really really
naive about this issue. This class has
really opened my eyes about how much the
US healthcare system SUCKS. We watched
most of Michael Moore's "Sicko" in
class..and I dont know if you've seen it
or not but there was one man who was
working and accidently sawed off the tips
of 2 fingers, his middle and his ring
finger. To reattach the middle finger
would cost $60,000 and to attach the ring
finger was 12,000. Given the financial
situation they were in his wife and he
could only have the ring finger
reattached. Basically same story happens
in Great Britain, guy saws off all 4
fingers...goes to the hospital and has all
of them reattached and there is no bill
issued due to their health care policy.
This ridiculous! In London the Doctors are
paid bonuses based on how many patients
they DONT see...meaning their patients
stay healthy, here in the United States,
the more money these doctors save by
denying treatment, the more money the
insurance companies save, so they get a
bonus basically by NOT doing their job!
This is INSANE! All the power is in the
insurance companies and I think thats a
huge problem...I was never worried about
health care(probably since Im under my
parents) but something needs to be done
here.
I was nearly in tears when the woman was
telling her story of how her husband had
cancer. They needed a donor for bone
marrow, found a perfect match in his
little brother and hoped his life could be
saved. Well, turns out their insurance
company considered this proceedure
"experimental" and refused to cover it.
Imagine being in that situation...having a
loved one fight cancer, finding a possible
solution and having your heart ripped out
because you cant afford it and your
insurance wont cover it. I cant imagine
being in this situation
so anyway, i'm done ranting..i just wanna
know how some of you feel about health
care where you're from...and if you're
from the US what do you think needs to be
done here???
Christ...they are showing Michael Moore
movies in class? I can't believe what some
of these nutty far-left professors will
stoop to. Michael Moore preys on the weak
minded to further his nonsense. He's been
doing it for almost 20 years now.
No....Universal health care does not work
and it's because of what KillBill said -
the delays. You will wait for
everything...Just had a heart attack? Sry,
you'll have to wait for treatment. Had
stroke? Have to wait. Oh, you have cancer,
do you? Gonna have to wait months for
treatment while that sucker spreads.
As far as healthcare in England is
concerned. If people are so satisfied with
their universal health care there, then
why does privatiezed health care keep
growing at an alarming rate?
And Cuba? There's no denying cuba's life
expectancy (which is still lower than the
U.S.), but to survey the people of a
communist nation, where thoughts are
controlled, are a bad idea. And indicatior
is the hundreds of Cuban doctors that keep
migrating to the U.S.
Come on, man. You are 21, do some research
on your own!
The examples I mentioned are rare
exceptions, one of which made national
headlines and prompted our regional health
authority to look at the problem and
address it. Personally, I think they were
both cases of racism more than anything.
You can't have a perfect system when you
have imperfect human beings running and
using it. I don't know of anyone who has
had to wait while they die of cancer but I
know of a lot of people who have had
cancer and haven't left their family with
tens of thousands of dollars in medical
bills. I live in Canada and I would not
want to live in the states. I don't think
any system is perfect but I prefer one
that is based on need, not on profit.
I don't think "Sicko" is the best place to
get your information on health care
systems. It's nice to "supplement" any
information, but I hope no one is getting
all of their information there.
That being said: I don't like socialized
health care. It fosters a society that
runs to the doctor for everything because
they can, and there is not competitive
rates for doctors.
1) People can't go to the doctor for
everyhting. If you've got a cold, get
rest, take the medicine you would
otherwise take/herbal supplements, and
only if things get worse...go over there.
I'm not saying people should wait until
things get horrible to go to the doctor.
Instead, I'm advocating that one lets
his/herr body work itself out before
he/she runs for medications that will lose
it's effectiveness the more you get it.
2) WE NEED DOCTORS. If a these doctors are
not paid an amount that is competitive, we
will lose doctors. I don't care what Moore
says in his movie...he can look all over
England and find at least one doctor who
feels comfortable in his wages. He
neglected to say anything about how there
is a private practice of dentists in the
UK; more dentists are moving over to the
private sector because they can be paid a
competitive amount rather than the general
salary provided by the government. Along
with the less competitive pays, we get
less doctors. Who would want to go through
school, paying thousands upon thousands of
dollars, and then go into a profession
that will demand you to spend DECADES to
pay off your debt? I'm sorry, but I am
more than willing to spend as much money
as possible to get the best care. At
least, as long as I can afford...which
brings me to my last point...
There should be a universal health
insurance program instead of universal
health care. Yay for that! Helath
insurance that provides coverage for
preventative care (already discussed) and
one that has pre-tax debti cards that can
be used for ANY medical service. Birch,
that is a horrible system to put upon
people. Giving people a tax break that
would allow you to purchase your own plan,
right for you is what you and all other
Americans need.
Just my two cents. Health care is a sticky
thing...
|
worrywart01
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 15 May 2008 Posts: 811 Location: ,
Thanks: 66
Thanked:11
Re: Healthcare Posted: 10-16-08 23:45pm
Marc209
wrote:
worrywart01
wrote:
I'm in a class called
healthy lifestyles and we're talking about
healthcare around the world. I'm 21, I'm
under my parents insurance still since i'm
still in college and was really really
naive about this issue. This class has
really opened my eyes about how much the
US healthcare system SUCKS. We watched
most of Michael Moore's "Sicko" in
class..and I dont know if you've seen it
or not but there was one man who was
working and accidently sawed off the tips
of 2 fingers, his middle and his ring
finger. To reattach the middle finger
would cost $60,000 and to attach the ring
finger was 12,000. Given the financial
situation they were in his wife and he
could only have the ring finger
reattached. Basically same story happens
in Great Britain, guy saws off all 4
fingers...goes to the hospital and has all
of them reattached and there is no bill
issued due to their health care policy.
This ridiculous! In London the Doctors are
paid bonuses based on how many patients
they DONT see...meaning their patients
stay healthy, here in the United States,
the more money these doctors save by
denying treatment, the more money the
insurance companies save, so they get a
bonus basically by NOT doing their job!
This is INSANE! All the power is in the
insurance companies and I think thats a
huge problem...I was never worried about
health care(probably since Im under my
parents) but something needs to be done
here.
I was nearly in tears when the woman was
telling her story of how her husband had
cancer. They needed a donor for bone
marrow, found a perfect match in his
little brother and hoped his life could be
saved. Well, turns out their insurance
company considered this proceedure
"experimental" and refused to cover it.
Imagine being in that situation...having a
loved one fight cancer, finding a possible
solution and having your heart ripped out
because you cant afford it and your
insurance wont cover it. I cant imagine
being in this situation
so anyway, i'm done ranting..i just wanna
know how some of you feel about health
care where you're from...and if you're
from the US what do you think needs to be
done here???
Christ...they are showing Michael Moore
movies in class? I can't believe what some
of these nutty far-left professors will
stoop to. Michael Moore preys on the weak
minded to further his nonsense. He's been
doing it for almost 20 years now.
No....Universal health care does not work
and it's because of what KillBill said -
the delays. You will wait for
everything...Just had a heart attack? Sry,
you'll have to wait for treatment. Had
stroke? Have to wait. Oh, you have cancer,
do you? Gonna have to wait months for
treatment while that sucker spreads.
As far as healthcare in England is
concerned. If people are so satisfied with
their universal health care there, then
why does privatiezed health care keep
growing at an alarming rate?
And Cuba? There's no denying cuba's life
expectancy (which is still lower than the
U.S.), but to survey the people of a
communist nation, where thoughts are
controlled, are a bad idea. And indicatior
is the hundreds of Cuban doctors that keep
migrating to the U.S.
Come on, man. You are 21, do some research
on your own!
first of all, my knowledge on health care
is limited as i stated in my previous
post...secondly, i do not by any means
agree with all of michael moores ideas or
opinions..i think for myself, however,
studying this topic in class and seeing
this movie has really opened my eyes about
our health care system which by the way
SUCKS...i never said we should have
universal health care i never proposed any
solution actually, i was simply
summarizing a few events in the movie to
further stress how much our system
SUCKS...things need to change..how about
you suggest a plan since you seem to know
everything