Relationships and Marriage Forum - Husband Is Never Emotionally Available
Medical questions     Health forums     MarketPlace    

Husband Is Never Emotionally Available

New Topic  Reply  Ask A Doctor - Offline
Medical Questions-> Health Forums -> Relationships and Marriage -> Husband Is Never Emotionally Available
Medical Questions
Author Message
november78

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 01 Aug 2007
Posts: 2
Husband Is Never Emotionally Available
Posted: 08-01-07 07:55am

I've been in a rocky marriage for 5 years and a half now. One of the main reasons why I think our marriage is so rocky is because my husband is never emotionally available. Whenever I'm feeling sad or worried about something, he would just ask me what is the problem, I'd tell him, then he'd reply non-empthatically in one sentence which invalidates my feelings somehow - like saying that I'm just being silly to think that way, I'm a silly woman, there's nothing to worry about, its a non-issue, etc.
After that, he'd just completely shut off from me about the issue, refusing to have any more discussion about it - he'd laze there on the couch watching the TV. All this, even when I have valid points to raise to him. He NEVER ever wants to have a good talk with me in private. It always HAS to be done with me sitting there trying to discuss something with him or raise an issue I'm worried/feel sad about, and him lying there on the couch in front of the TV watching TV at the same time as "listening" to me.
If I feel the issue is of importance to me and I want him to really listen to me with full attention, and I ask him if he wants to go into the room and had a talk with me, he'd either say no or he'd get up slowly and grudgingly, and then go to the room, and after maybe listening to me the first few sentences and then replying in a few non-empathic, dismissing sentences, he'd get up and leave the room within 3 minutes and then absolutely refuse to have any more discussion about it again.

Its not that I think I'm full of importance and demand to be heard. I am just looking for a bit of emotional reassurance from him if I'm worried/upset about something, a bit of empathy, if you like.
He's worse than my friends because if I go to my friends, they will always validate my feelings and answer my worries and they are never dismissive about it.

Whatever happened to the marriage vows of showing support for each other in times of need, etc? My husband is emotionally cut off from me most times and is only interested in helping out in practical aspects of the marriage like helping to do some housework, bringing in money to help support family, going down to the shops to buy groceries we need, cooking. All those things he's very happy to help out with.

My mum keeps telling me my husband isn't that bad because he always insists on cooking for everyone (he says he does it because he thinks my cooking is not very good and because I am not a fast cooker and he doesn't like having to wait for his food)... and also she thinks he's great because he actually helps out with housework ... and she thinks he's good because he earns a lot of money at work and always gives a lot of it back to the family. I know compared to my own dad, my husband is much better because my own dad was a very conservative, traditional man who treated my mum like a subordinate and never cooks/cleans/wants to take care of the emotional side of things in the relationship.

But in this day and age, I just don't think my husband is that great?? Not only is he emotionally distant and seldom talks much to me about his own feelings about things - hence leaving me to do all the guesswork and mind-reading, which can be disastrously wrong - he's also very stingy towards me and never buys presents for me or gives me any spending money. Whenever it comes to grocery shopping or when I need to go shop for clothes for myself or the kids, he always insists on tagging along and footing the bill instead of giving me money to contribute towards the shopping and letting me go grocery shopping on my own. He wants complete control over how his money is spent and everything. I've given up my career when I had my first child and have been a stay-at-home mum for the past 5 years looking after two children. I intend to go back to work when my youngest reaches 3. Previously when we had no children and I was working and earning a regular income, my husband never interferes in the way I choose to spend my own hard-earned cash. But if I ever have to depend on him financially, like since I became a stay at home mum, he would get very controlling about what I spend the money on and refuses to let me make decisions on spending unless I ask him for approval.

But he's not that nasty... he always calls me up during lunch break to say "hi" to me, to ask "Hi, how's things at home? Everything okay?" in a gentle voice. ALWAYS. It drives me mad. Why is he acting so nice during work? I could actually tell him any issues I have with the landlords, etc... and he would listen very carefully and give me some reassuring replies to help, and if I told him we were out of milk or something at home, he would always say "Alright, I'll stop by the shop before coming home to get those things. Is there anything else you need?" But whenever he comes home he's a pain in the butt for me to live with. I get the feeling he just doesn't want all the emotional hassle of the marriage - he doesn't want to get involved with the emotional side of things. He doesn't like any sort of negativity, sadness or worrying coming from me about anything, because if I show those aspects of myself, he instantly switches off and becomes like he doesn't want to hear anything about it.


Does any of you think this sort of relationship is actually normal and that I'm making a big fuss out of nothing?
|
Willa Weintraub

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 05 Mar 2007
Posts: 3399
Location: The Beach!
Thanks: 30
Thanked:46

Posted: 08-01-07 09:43am

In no way are you making a big fuss about it.This is a huge part of the relationship,along with communication. If you don't have those,you don't have anything. This is a big deal and it sounds like he needs to gt it together. Has he always been like this,even before marriage? My ex was the same way and I couldn't handle all the guessing games and trying to heold it together for the both of us.Maybe you could go to marriage counceling? have you brought that up to him?
|
november78

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 01 Aug 2007
Posts: 2

Posted: 08-01-07 10:08am

~*~Melissa~*~ wrote:
In no way are you making a big fuss about it.This is a huge part of the relationship,along with communication. If you don't have those,you don't have anything. This is a big deal and it sounds like he needs to gt it together. Has he always been like this,even before marriage? My ex was the same way and I couldn't handle all the guessing games and trying to heold it together for the both of us.Maybe you could go to marriage counceling? have you brought that up to him?


I have mentioned marriage counselling to him a few times before but he is never enthusiastic about it. He said if I want it, I must organise it myself and he will try to take the appropriate day off for it. He also would prefer if he didn't have to pay for the counselling. I did look through the marriage counselling services available and there seems so many to choose from. I don't know which one is better, which one to take, is it worth paying for a service, are the free/charity ones worth it - are they as good as the ones you actually pay for? I heard some people who've went through RELATE counselling services say that RELATE counseller only helped to worsen the relationship. I'm not sure what to do now at this point. I know my husband obviously isn't interested in listening to me. He thinks I don't know half the things I'm talking about. Then he says that his ex-girlfriend was a psychologist and she helped turn his personality into a better one because she was very smart - though he didn't love her. So I'm not a psychologist, he obviously doesn't want to take anything I say or suggest seriously. I think marriage counselling might work for us - if the counsellor is credible and is someone he will listen to... but I don't know which one to approach and am worried it will just worsen the situation??
|
Willa Weintraub

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 05 Mar 2007
Posts: 3399
Location: The Beach!
Thanks: 30
Thanked:46

Posted: 08-01-07 10:57am

for you to even suggest marriage councelig is a step i the right direction. If he is willing to go take a look around,maybe see if you can find testimonials from people on the net? If it makes the situation worse,it's him not you and you should always remember that! You are willnig to try and hold things together.What if he does have to pay for it? Tell him if he wants this marriage to work it doesn't matter if the visits need to be payed for. Tell him to stop being so tight with his money because this is something that will benefit you both.If not,well I guess you have a very tough decision to make.I hope everything turns out well.please keep me updated!
|
Georgia59

Moderator
Joined: 11 Apr 2007
Posts: 5557
Location: Along the Mississippi, USA
Thanks: 90
Thanked:32

Posted: 08-08-07 11:35am

I'll go out on a limb here.

He sounds like he really does care. To him, helping with housework, calling on his lunchbreak, and stuff is his way of showing he cares. But you need a different kind of communication (like, with words lol) and maybe if you just talk to him about it, tell him you need more intimate together time (without the tv) he'll get it.

Schedule dates where the tv isn't involved?

Of course marriage counseling is always a good idea, but then you have to convince him to go.

Good luck.
|
Related Topics
This Forum This Category All Forums
Jump to:  
New Topic   Reply
Medical Questions -> Health Forums -> Relationships and Marriage -> Husband Is Never Emotionally Available



We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.