Hello everyone
Years ago I have been diagnosed with DDD
at C3-4. It was not bad, once every couple
of years I get sever pain in my neck for
about a week. This pain is really bad, you
wish you can cut your head off and it is
not relieved by sitting or laying down.
Because it is infrequest it is not a
concern, however, my lower back is. I was
also diagnosed year ago with DDD at L3-4
and L4-5, actually nothing shows of L4-5
disc on xray.
The advise I was given is put up with the
lower back pain for as long as you can,
and for years I learned to cope. I use
voltaren, the neck pain comes only every
few years.
I have several neuros, pain management
clinic, therapists.
Actually, the neuro and pm doc can not
really diagnose were the pain is coming
from ?
Decpite MRI's, CT Scans, discograms and
xrays they could not diagnose the source
of pain.
DISCGRAM: Years ago when I did the test,
they would inject the saline and ask me if
this is the pain ?,no, how about now?, not
really, how is this? May be. It was very
inconclusive. But, when I got up and
stood, OUCH , THIS IS THE PAIN. This time
when I do the discodram I’ll ask to do
one injection at a time then get up and
stand after each injection.
Now, I get the lower back pain only when I
stand or walk for three minutes and the
pain is in lower back, not in legs, or
thighs or hips. The pain always relieved
when I sit down. There is continuous very
slight numb sensation at the upper skin
surface of my left thigh ( continuous
meaning, all the time even while rested ).
My lower back pain is getting worse and I
have made the decision to do something.
I am scheduled to see my neuro next week.
I have not seen him in two years because I
was hoping to lose weight and see if that
help. Needless to say I did not lose
weight . This time I ask him to do new
MRI, discogram, etc. I’ll ask what he
can do and get his opinion of the laser
places ( I can guess what he will say !).
Called United Health they said Tolli and
microspine are in the network, LSI and
Bonati are not.
By the way, the reason I had to put up
with pain, at 45 I had AVN and had to have
THR - total hip replacement. Now I need to
take care of my lower back. Question: Has
any one complained from pain in lower back
only (no lower extremities issues). In so
far as open back vs. laser center, nothing
is perfect the out come is 50-50. But when
it comes to which laser center the choice
is not clear.
Mel
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 823
Thanks: 16
Thanked:0
CONGRATULATIONS MEL!!!! Posted: 03-28-08 18:05pm
Hello Mel,
CONGRATULATIONS on posting the 1000th post
on this thread Mel. Thanks for all that
you have shared in your post. We learn
from each other.
It is truly amazing all the wonderful
spineys who have contributed so much on
this thread. And it keeps on rolling!!!
RichT
|
tjh299
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Nov 2007 Posts: 17
alsgodoc Posted: 03-28-08 18:30pm
i need some help again if you don't mind.
we couldn't go to chicago for standing
mri, but had a regular one done, and was
wondering if you could tell me if anything
sounds like it needs to be address by
surgery? Sagittal findings: There is
minimal, grade ! anterolisthesis of L5 on
S1. no associated fracture. Verebral
bodies demonstrate normal height and
signal intensity on all sequences. the
conus medullaris is at L1-L2, and the
spinal cord demonstrates normal signal
intensity on all sequences. There is
mild desiccation, loss of height,
associated endplate irregularity, and a
likely annular tear at L5-S1. Signal void
and soft tissue enhancement in the
posterior papspinal tissues on the left is
consistant with postoperative change. He
has lower bakc pain that runs from his
back down the back of the legs, all the
way to his toes. the left side is more
prominent than the right. but he has
narrowing of the right lateral recess with
compression of the traversing right S1
nerve root. could the mild to moderate
bulge's that he has on level L2-L3, L3-L4,
and L4-L5 and bilateral facet arthropathy
also on those levels be causing him more
pain than the L5-S1 issue? I hate to see
him in such pain . I sure would apprecaite
your opinion. Have you had any flooding
like missouri? We live close to the
meramec river, but far enough that we
didn't get any damage. There sure are alot
of people having to clean up a big mess,
hopefully the goverment will help.
Thanks for taking time to respond. Mary
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 823
Thanks: 16
Thanked:0
Posted: 03-31-08 19:09pm
Hello Mary,
In my opinion it is for your husband's
doctor to interprete the MRI report and
the MRI images, rather than any of us
"spiney's".
With the above said -
"He has lower bakc pain that runs from his
back down the back of the legs, all the
way to his toes." Mary, I can only speak
from my experience. For me when I had
pain going down my leg it was determined
both from the MRI and from the pain I had
that I had a pinched nerve at L3/L4.
May I encourage your husband to talk to
his doctor and his doctor's thoughts
regarding tryiing an epidural injection.
SOOooooo very glad that you did not
receive any flood damage to your home.
Take care.
RichT
|
littleonefb
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 11 Aug 2007 Posts: 157 Location: ,
Thanks: 2
Thanked:0
wow, so many posts. Posted: 03-31-08 19:55pm
Hello to all,
I'm amazed at how many posts are here now
and I've sure got a lot of catching up to
do and maybe some responses to some as
well.
Give me some time to catch up.
Fran
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 823
Thanks: 16
Thanked:0
Posted: 03-31-08 21:34pm
Hello Fran,
We have missed you!!!!
Look forward to your spiney thoughts.
RichT
|
algosdoc
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Mar 2004 Posts: 186
Posted: 04-01-08 06:39am
I agree 100% with Rich. An internet forum
is no place to try to reinterpret a
written report of a MRI that a. may not
correlate to the visual images since each
radiologist has their own interpretation
of the images and b. may produce
extraneous and conflicting interpretations
that may not at all correlate to your
physical symptoms.
|
littleonefb
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 11 Aug 2007 Posts: 157 Location: ,
Thanks: 2
Thanked:0
Mary Posted: 04-01-08 07:13am
I also agree that you need to have your
husband's spine surgeon explain the
findings on your husband's MRI to both of
you.
MRI reports are only 1 part of a
diagnostic evaluation of spinal problems.
It is a tool that a good doctor will use
to help match the symptoms to the
findings.
Many people have various degrees of bulges
to their spinals discs and they mean
nothing, unless the correlate to symptoms
that patient exhibits, such as pain,
weakness etc.
It is quite possible to take those MRI
films to several different radiologists
and to several different spinal surgeons
and some of them or all of them may have
different interpretations of them.
I had that experience when seeking other
opinions before my spinal surgery. I
actually had a total of 5 different
diagnosis and 5 different interpretations
of my MRI results. Plus I had a 6th one
from my original spinal surgeon.
I returned to my original surgeon for my
surgery, because his diagnosis, and
interpretation made the most sense to me,
my husband and a friend who is a nurse,
and I felt the most comfortable with him.
My suggestion to you is for you and your
husband to sit down and discuss the
results of your husband's MRI and if you
are not satisfied with his/her answers and
or plan of treatment , then I would seek
further opinions until you find a doctor
that can help your husband.
Glad to hear you had no flooding damage.
Fran
|
littleonefb
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 11 Aug 2007 Posts: 157 Location: ,
Thanks: 2
Thanked:0
Financial Costs of Laser Spine Surgery Posted: 04-01-08 07:42am
Regarding the costs of surgery mentioned
in a couple of posts here for LSI and what
Algosdoc says the costs are for him.
This is really very disturbing to me.
Specifically Plasma Disc Decompression.
My mind is just blown away at what LSI
charged fenarrito for a plasma disc
decompression and that didn't include
travel to and from Florida, housing, food
etc.
Never mind the fact that it is not a laser
procedure
My math calculator came up with a figure
of $16,000. And Algosdoc stated it
shouldn't be much more than $5,000
maximum.
That is $11,000 more at LSI and this
procedure is covered by insurance when
done by spinal surgeons that are not part
of the laser facilities.
The most a patient would have to pay would
be a co-pay if that is required for sugery
and day surgery procedures.
A friend of my husband and I had this done
2 months ago at a major Boston MA hospital
and they just got the insurance paid
receipt info last week in the mail. BC/BS
of MA paid the bill in it's entirety minus
their $75 co-pay. Including the doctor's
bill, the total bill was an even $6,000.
Again $10,000 less than LSI.
That really disturbs me to no end,
especially considering that they did not
do anything differently than any other
spinal surgeon would do that does not do
laser spinal surgery.
Just leads me to ask these questions?
What is up with the incredibly high charge
for this type of procedure?
And why would anyone go to any laser spine
facility for this procedure and pay such a
high price for it and have to pay for it
out of their own wallet?
Fran
|
littleonefb
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 11 Aug 2007 Posts: 157 Location: ,
Thanks: 2
Thanked:0
Re: LSI Posted: 04-01-08 07:56am
beetle-sac
wrote:
Matt:
I received a Percutaneous Arthoroscopic
Discectomy (L3-L4 bulging) in August at
LSI and had good results. My Surgery was
performed by Dr. Weiss, with a consult by
Dr. Wolff. My initial exam/eval was
completed by Dr. Rothman who seems to no
longer be there. My initial payment was
$5000.00 less than yours, (although they
have 100% of any insurance payments from
my BC/BS etc.); I was scheduled on a very
short term basis (I guess I replaced
someone who canceled out).
On the day of my surgery I was taken
wonderful care of by the OR staff, the
Nurse Anestitist, and the Anesthesiologist
Dr Hamburg. The surgery took just about 75
minutes, and then they moved me to the
recovery area to sober up. Around an hour
later I walked out of there without the
usual pain in my leg/groin/shin.
I walked around our Hotel complex, and the
following day visited SeaWorld with my 9
year old son and my wife. I needed to rest
frequently - but I was considerably
better. I also visited Dr Kellogg, and
learned several things from him that have
helped me quite a bit.
After returning home to New Jersey I
completed 8 weeks of physical therapy to
help me stand and walk straight; and
gradually succeeded.
Now for the down side; after about 3
months of being TOTALLY PAIN FREE, I had
the misfortune of getting out of the
recliner / couch incorrectly and pulled
something. I could not stand or walk
without alot of help for a week, and it's
now been over 8 weeks - I'm getting a
little better every day, but it's still
there. The Pain seems to be coming from
L4-L5 according to my pain specialist. The
next step is steroid injections in a
couple weeks.
I have not been in touch with LSI for
quite a while; a few weeks post surgery I
needed a renewal script for my PT and they
sent it right away, but they have not
followed up with me at all, so much for
the phone calls every few weeks to check
on me... (I've heard this from others,
too).
Another down-side is if I need an
additional surgery it will be another cash
payment of $14,000 or $15,000 minimum -
which will take at least three magic
tricks and a miracle to come up with...
Well, theres my tale-of-woe.. I
sincerely hope that you're final result
will turn out far better than mine, and on
the plus side - my son is still talking
about Sea World, and yep I would probably
do it all over again tomorrow..
Best Regards,
Mike B (Beetle)
PS: For my friend RichT, theres my
progress report!! Hope all is GREAT with
you!!
Sorry to hear that you now have continued
or new problems since your surgery, but I
am not surprised to hear that LSI has not
continued to follow up with phone calls to
you.
I to have read on other sites that they
don't follow up as they say they do.
It may be that they will be willing to do
more surgery for you and free or reduced
prices, but it would still entail travel
to LSI and lodging again.
I would consider staying local and trying
the ESI for now and see how that works
out. If need be, you might prefer to stay
local for further surgery and have your
insurance pay for it this time.
Fran
|
littleonefb
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 11 Aug 2007 Posts: 157 Location: ,
Thanks: 2
Thanked:0
Re: Opposing Sides Posted: 04-01-08 08:39am
RichT
wrote:
Hello Babs,
Welcome to this forum and the great people
who post and try to help others. And of
course a very special warm welcome to this
thread.
An EXCELLENT question!!! No different
today than it has been for the history of
mankind (or more appropriately for
humankind). Any time in history that
someone has steped out of the "box" they
get stomped on by the "establishment". It
never ends. I have been there, so I
know.
It is the "establishment" of the
traditional way to treat back pain against
a newer way. The medical establishment
"controls" the procedures "approved" by
the insurance companies. The laser docs
control their turf by not openly
publishing. Both are in error.
Just think what Galileo went through
saying the earth rotated around the sun
rather than the "establishment" and church
saying the sun rotated around the earth.
Hope this gives some perspective.
"Keep it coming." Babs, I can't imagine
this lively group of spineys every slowing
down. lol They truly "energize" me.
Something those I meet face to face with
don't even come close to doing.
RichT
Rich,
I see the issues of these opposing sides
very differently and put the reason for
them totally in the hands of the Laser
spine doctors.
Insurance companies have legitimate
reasons for denying payment for laser
spine surgery.
They want to be shown that it really is an
effective treatment for spinal problems
and not some kind of experimental
procedure.
They are asking for proof, just as any
other procedure or surgery would be
required to be justified.
To qualify for insurance payments, the
laser spine surgeons would have to do
proper studies to verify their procedures
"work", are equally as good or better than
traditional spinal surgery and warrant
being done and paid for.
Insurance Companies will not accept
various information provided from foreign
countries, so called testing. They
require the studies be done here under the
regulations of this country.
As it stands right now, the laser spine
facilities are not interested in doing any
of these studies to verify that what they
say is true about their methods of doing
surgery. They are not interested in
providing the information to other
doctors, unless they are employed by one
of the facilities and trained in their
methods.
This would lead one to believe that they
prefer it this way. They get to charge
the exorbitant fees that they do,
advertise on the web in the fashion that
they do and make it appear that their
methods are far superior to traditional
spinal surgery with the slick websites and
all but sure fired promises that they can
fix your problems and prevent fusions and
all the rest that they claim.
As for reluctance of traditional spinal
surgeons to accept laser spinal surgery as
a new method for spinal surgery.
It's not really fair to make that kind of
claim. In so much as there is so little
information available to traditional
spinal surgeons on the surgery, it's no
wonder they are suspicious, wouldn't
recommend it, or say it is any good. They
aren't allowed to find out anything about
it really. It is kept a closely guarded
secret. The information that traditional
spinal surgeons find on the subject is not
much more than the patient finds out from
going to their websites.
Until the laser spinal surgeons are
willing to do what is needed to have their
surgery methods accepted by main stream
medicine, accepted for payment by
insurance companies, they will always be
looked at with great suspicion and
distrust.
Only the laser spine surgeons can change
this situation, and until they are willing
to do so, the opposing opinions will
continue to exist.
It certainly makes me wonder why they
continue to create this problem, all the
while making millions of dollars off the
patients, many of whom can't really afford
the surgery and go deeply into debt to pay
for something that may or may not be the
best surgery for them, though they are led
to believe it is a miracle cure for their
spinal pain.
One other thing I would point out as well.
The more is look at various other spinal
sites on line, I find more and more people
that have had laser surgery and have had
poor results; and those results are coming
from all of the laser spinal facilities,
not any one in particular.
Fran
|
fenarrito
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 26 Mar 2008 Posts: 8
littleone Posted: 04-01-08 15:15pm
Hey there,
I just read your post and am very
happy to see you are interested in my fees
from LSI. I noticed that you didn't
mention that I also received a laser facet
nerve "removal" on two levels. Maybe the
procedure on the nerves is why my fees
were higher than you thought they should
be. I don't know. What I do know is that I
have been thoroughly satisfied, so far,
with the service I have received and feel
I paid a fair amount to have a group
perform a medical procedure on me. If I
don't get out of this pain I'm in I will
probably have a different view at a later
time. I was told by every conventional
Dr./Surgeon I interviewed not to go to
LSI. So I tried to find some dirt on any
of the staff involved with the institute.
I couldn't find any except that Dr.
Kellogg, PT Dr., had at one time been
listed as an MD on the LSI website yet he
is not an MD. I went straight to him and
confronted him about it and he said it was
a web master's mistake and he had it
changed. Who knows? Maybe bull, maybe not.
There are apparently several qualified and
very great surgeons around the US that
could have done this procedure as good or
better than LSI, and for cheaper, but I
found LSI not them. By deduction I can
only come to reason that LSI spent more on
marketing than other surgery centers and
therefore have a reflective price. I did
receive a check for 1k for lodging. Are
there things I would have changed about my
visit to LSI? Of course. I will list a few
for those considering a procedure. That is
why we are here, right? This all depending
on the idea my procedure has taken me out
of pain and allowed me to surf, jog, and
lift again. Right now I'm still in pain
from the procedure.
1. I would have better researched PDD
before I went to LSI
a. I was only well researched on
discectomy
2. I may not have had the nerves burned
off in my facet joints
a. I needed more time to research that
procedure
3. I would have gotten more patients
telephone numbers for my own follow up
questions
a. Right now I only have 2 people's
numbers that I met getting a PDD at LSI
b. While at LSI I spoke to at least
50, probably more, people who were with
someone having, having, or had had a
procedure there (not one complaint from
them)
c. There were 2 people who had been
flown back to have follow up or reparatory
surgery by LSI, and one that had PDD that
wasn't successful, I think
4. I wish to God I would have gone there
years ago
I am sure I would have changed other
things about the whole escapade, and
probably will be changing some things in
the future, but over all I can't say it
has been bad at all. My progress is as
follows: Healing and hurting, hoping and
praying, feeling desperate and
wondering...I am sure I will heal and be
happy, any other outlook would be
detrimental to my recovery. If anyone can
give me a success or failure story for PDD
please do, I am starved for information.
Thank you, Matt
|
tjh299
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Nov 2007 Posts: 17
to all that replied Posted: 04-01-08 18:59pm
I wasn't wanting anyone to operate on my
spouse, he has a pain managment dr. that
we will see friday, but was curious to
have an opinion, just as fran said , that
go to 5 doctors; get 5 different opinions.
It's just nice to be able to talk to other
people about problems. My spouse doesn't
even know that i have mentioned anything
about his condition. So it's not like i'm
telling him that this is what they said on
the thread. This is what we have to do.
Give me a little bit of credit, i'm not
the kind to see or hear something on the
web and think it is gospel, cause we know
that's not true. No hard feelings for
alsgodoc, was just asking for an opinion,
causing he has had very good information
about things that could help. Thanks
anyway!!!!!!!!! god bless Mary
|
algosdoc
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Mar 2004 Posts: 186
Posted: 04-01-08 20:47pm
No problemo. One absolutely must have the
patient in front of them to make an
accurate diagnosis from MRI films so that
clinical correlation may be made. A
radiologist's interpretation of the MRI is
yet one step further removed from the
truth. (remember, radiologists are
technicians, not clinicians....they rarely
ever examine a patient)
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 823
Thanks: 16
Thanked:0
Some Thoughts Posted: 04-02-08 18:45pm
Hello Fran,
You have been most fortunate to have a
SUPERB traditional spine surgeon. They
are far and few between. I know that from
the many posts i have read, and also from
my personal interactions with traditional
spine surgeons.
Joe (Joebob) saw 12-13 traditional spine
surgeons and they all pretty much said
there was nothing they could do for him to
reduce his pain. That he had to learn to
live with it. Joe as you know had surgery
at the Bonati Institute. In our/my last
communications with Joe he was living life
to the fullest and coaching ice hockey.
AND his health insurance paid a goodly
portion of the costs for his surgery at
Bonati.
Fran, I think it unfair to "label" the
laser spine institutes as TOTALLY bad as
you have. Yes, they market themselves and
their services. Yes, their fees may be
higher than some others. HOWEVER, other
traditional spine institutes also market
themselves and some I'm sure charge more
than Algosdoc does.
True, the laser institutes have not
published thier procedures in the accepted
medical journals. However, to be fair, I
doubt that all traditional spinal surgeons
publish all their procedures. In
addition, it is possible that they have
tried to publish their work, but that
their submitted manuscripts were not
accepted by the established "club". I
know how it is when an "outsider" tries to
publish in the "club" journals. It is
almost impossible to do so.
Regarding surgery failings - I do not have
information on that from the laser spine
institutes, nor do I have it regarding
traditional spine surgery facilities. A
"successful" surgery outcome is a most
difficult thing to quantify. There are
just SOOooo many factors that can enter
in.
You have your thoughts, and it is fine to
share them. That is what an open forum is
all about. And I will stand by the
thoughts I shared in my post that you
quoted.
RichT
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 823
Thanks: 16
Thanked:0
Posted: 04-02-08 19:33pm
Hello Matt,
Thank you for all that you have shared
with us. I was most impressed with your
open honest thoughts.
"Are there things I would have changed
about my visit to LSI? Of course. I will
list a few for those considering a
procedure. That is why we are here,
right?" YES Matt, that is precisely why
we have forums and are here. To be able
to share our concerns, thoughts, advice
with each other.
I liked every point you made in your list.
EXCELLENT food for thought for everyone.
Okay, lets flip the coin to the other side
- traditonal spine surgery. Every single
point you made in your list would still
apply in my opinion. When I asked my
traditional spine surgeon EXACTLY what was
he going to do during his proposed surgery
to my back his reply was "Two fusions and
perhaps a laminectomy. Really can't say
until I open you up". WELLLlllll, that
may all be true, however, I needed and
need a better reply than that!!! Fran's
doc from what she has shared with us told
her everything in detail. I only wish we
all could have a doc like that.
A side note - About this time last year
all the spinal surgeons and my to be pain
mainagement doctor at the institute got
together and the surgeons discussed what
surgery they should do or not do regarding
my messed up back. From what I am told
opinions varied greatly. After much
discussion my PM doc spoke up and said
"Hold it! Don't you think we should first
give some nonsurgical options a try?" The
surgeons agreed (probably reluctantly so).
My past two epidural injections have kept
me functioning. (Translated - I can still
get my hands dirty in our gardens, twist,
turn, bend, and lift "weights".) Tomorrow
morning I go for my third epidural. Hope
like the others it too keeps the knife
away from me.
I wish you the very best in your recovery
Matt.
RichT
|
tjh299
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Nov 2007 Posts: 17
Rich T Posted: 04-02-08 19:55pm
Just a note for you , on tomorrow's
journey, GOOD LUCK and I WILL BE THINKING
OF YOU!!!!!!!!!!!! Mary
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 823
Thanks: 16
Thanked:0
Posted: 04-03-08 10:43am
Hello Mary,
Thanks for your thoughts and concern.
The epidural injection went well this
morning. No back pain at this time, but
of course that is because the lidocaine
hasn't worn off yet. Tomorrow will give
me a better idea if my PM doc is still
doing his "magic".
RichT
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 823
Thanks: 16
Thanked:0
Severing Pain Nerves Posted: 04-03-08 16:27pm
Hello Matt,
I hope your recovery is going well. Do
stay in touch and give us an update now
and then.
I would like to go back to one of the
points you listed in your post.
"2. I may not have had the nerves burned
off in my facet joints"
Matt, I'm glad you brought up the subject.
The severing of the pain nerves by
whatever means has concerned me. It is
not just the laser institutes that do this
procedure, but also traditional spine
doctors. Even my PM doc has told me he
does it.
What concerns me about severing the pain
nerves, is that then you do not know when
something is wrong. Ones brain does not
get what to me is an important signal.
Yes, I understand that for those in sever
pain, and where every other option
including surgery has been attempted and
failed, then it would seem to be the only
option left.
However Matt, it seems to be a procedure
that for some doctors is almost a routine
part of spine surgery. It is a way for
the surgery to be a "success" because now
the patient feels no pain. Far better in
my opinion to NOT sever the pain nerves
until one finds out if the cause of the
pain has been addressed successfully
during surgery ore by some other means.
Those are my thoughts on the subject. I'd
be interested in knowing the thoughts of
everyone.
Hope you are having a GREAT Day!!!
RichT
|
littleonefb
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 11 Aug 2007 Posts: 157 Location: ,
Thanks: 2
Thanked:0
Re: Severing Pain Nerves Posted: 04-03-08 17:06pm
RichT
wrote:
Hello Matt,
I hope your recovery is going well. Do
stay in touch and give us an update now
and then.
I would like to go back to one of the
points you listed in your post.
"2. I may not have had the nerves burned
off in my facet joints"
Matt, I'm glad you brought up the subject.
The severing of the pain nerves by
whatever means has concerned me. It is
not just the laser institutes that do this
procedure, but also traditional spine
doctors. Even my PM doc has told me he
does it.
What concerns me about severing the pain
nerves, is that then you do not know when
something is wrong. Ones brain does not
get what to me is an important signal.
Yes, I understand that for those in sever
pain, and where every other option
including surgery has been attempted and
failed, then it would seem to be the only
option left.
However Matt, it seems to be a procedure
that for some doctors is almost a routine
part of spine surgery. It is a way for
the surgery to be a "success" because now
the patient feels no pain. Far better in
my opinion to NOT sever the pain nerves
until one finds out if the cause of the
pain has been addressed successfully
during surgery ore by some other means.
Those are my thoughts on the subject. I'd
be interested in knowing the thoughts of
everyone.
Hope you are having a GREAT Day!!!
RichT
Hi Rich
There always seems to be a misconception
about "burning nerves".
I know I've posted about it before, but
too many posts to go back and check for it
so will repost the information that I have
been consistently told by several spine
surgeons and pain management docs,
including my own.
The nerves that are involved in ablation
or rhizotomy, which is what this is called
are "minor nerves". They come from the
facet area and can be the cause of a lot
of pain, especially sciatica.
The nerves are not really "burned off" but
are severed so that there is a space
between 2 ends in the nerves.
It can provide varying amounts of pain
relief, from mild to moderate to total
pain relief.
What usually isn't understood is this is
only a temporary fix. These minor nerves
regenerate, and the pain will return.
The pain relief can last anywhere from a
couple of weeks all the way to about 18
months before it returns.
The laser facilities seem to be the only
ones that do it as "part of surgery".
What I will call "traditional spine
surgeons" do not do nerve
ablation/rhizotomy.
Pain management doctors are the ones that
do the nerve ablation/rhizotomy and they
use radio frequency to do it and it's
called radio frequency nerve ablation or
rhizotomy.
The usual method to determine if the
ablation will be successful is to do what
is called lidocaine injections to the
facet joints, one facet at a time.
Instead of steroid injections ie ESI,
lidocaine is injected into specific facet
joints that is suspected of causing the
pain.
Over a 10 hour time span, the patient
records the amount of pain relief that
they have in very great detail.
The results of those lidocaine injections
and the amount of pain relief determine
whether nerve ablation will help decrease
and/or eliminate the pain that the patient
is having.
Traditional doctors turn the possibility
of nerve ablation over to a pain
management doctor for evaluation and to be
done, long after the patient has exhibited
continued pain after fully recovering from
whatever spinal surgery they have had
done.
Never ablation can be repeated over and
over again if the patient wants to have it
done, but they have to remember it is only
a temporary fix and the nerves will
regenerate.
There is quite a bit of information on
radio frequency nerve ablation/rhizotomy
on the web. Just google either words or
both and you will find quite a bit of
information.
The site is not a replacement for professional medical opinion, examination, diagnosis or treatment. Always seek the advice of your medical doctor or other qualified health professional before starting any new treatment or making any changes to existing treatment. Do not delay seeking or disregard medical advice based on information written by any author on this site. No health questions and information on eHealth Forum is regulated or evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration and therefore the information should not be used to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease without the supervision of a medical doctor. Posts made to these forums express the views and opinions of the author, and not the administrators, moderators, or editorial staff and hence eHealth Forum and its principals will accept no liabilities or responsibilities for the statements made.
Schizophreniahealth
This page was last updated on June 11, 2008