Hello Marie.
Had I went for the fusion, there would
have been 4 titanium cages with rods and
screws. It would be done with iliac crest
bonegraft with the possible use of
demineralixed bone matrix.Along with that
he was going to due a posterior lumbar
decompression and anything else that
needed to be done while he was in there.I
can't erase the 40yrs. of smoking.He said
the fusion might not take place and I
would need another surgery the next
year.So it very well could have taken
2yrs. and not work in the end.NO THANKS.
As far as Bonati goes, I wish I knew what
they had planned. I won't know until I
get there and they do their two days of
tests. That is one of the parts that I
don't like. I live 1,200 miles away and I
couldn't afford to go for two day of tests
and come home and think about it and then
schedule my surgeries.
They looked at my MRI's and said I would
need at least three surgeries. Even
though I rented a condo for three weeks
and paid for plane tickets, if I don't
like what I hear, I will leave.
I was hoping that I would hear from somone
who has been there recently. I read about
JoeBob and Innovator. It sounds like they
did good. I have an awful lot wrong with
my back. I'm hoping that they start with
L4/5, then L3/4 and L2/3.
After reading all of my surgeons reports
and six MRI's, I think they are the worst
areas.
I choose Bonati over LSI because they
wanted to MRI films, not the reports. I
sent the reports to LSI and they called
and said, "Come on down. We'll fix you
right up." I've talked to people who have
been there and they were happy. It just
seems like a back factory to me. 400
procedures a month. One person told me
that you go in at 7:00 am for surgery and
just wait for your turn. He waited five
hours. I hope Bonati isn't so bad.
I won't be rushing home to work. I've
been on disability for six years. The
past six months, my back gets to the point
around 3:00 pm that I can't stand or sit.
I eat my dinner laying on my dining room
floor.
Well, I went pretty long with this. Thank
you.
|
Carrianne
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Aug 2007 Posts: 107 Location: Tampa, FL
Posted: 02-06-08 09:27am
Jerseyboy,
I had 2 surgeries at Bonati back in
August. Feel free to ask me any questions
you may have.
Best wishes and God bless,
Carrianne
|
Marie B.
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 28 Aug 2007 Posts: 231 Location: Ohio
Jersey Boy Posted: 02-06-08 11:41am
Let me say that I believe you have studied
your spine problem well. And you are
basing your decisions on your own sound
judgment. I particularly liked your
thinking that if you didn't like what was
said to Bonati that in spite of all of the
costs you would pack up and fly back home
if you didn't like what you were hearing.
This tells me that as bad as the pain you
are experiencing is, you will not be
allowing the pain nor emotions influence
your decision. This is good!
Carrianne's offer to be a source of
information for you is truly an example of
what good hearted and compassionate people
we have on this Forum. She will be a
great help in various ways for you.
Now, having said that permit me to add,
your hope in getting to talk to Joebob is
understandable. I don't know if Joebob is
posting on other Forums on other spinal
websites but Joebob is an example of
having a great "attitude" in approaching
his spinal surgery. In fact, I believe
Joebob's experience has energized a lot of
people to consider the laser institutes.
I also believe Joebob should have gotten
an incentive pay for all of his
advertising of his experience with laser
surgery, but I don't think he got
anything. Frankly, when I read....almost
a year ago....when Joebob went for his
surgery, his commentary on what his spinal
problem was, I don't think it compares to
what you are describing as your problems
and surgical advice. The one thing we all
have or had in common is "screamming,
exhausting and emotional pain from our
spinal problems which have brought all of
us to this table of decision
making.....what type of surgery or no
surgery should we have.
Joebob did not post a lot on this Forum,
but if you google Laser Surgery, you will
find there is an old Forum on Spine
Health.com (that particular thread is now
defunct) which was still available when I
last looked where Joebob was communicating
lots of information to everyone who was
following Laser Surgery at that time.
Hope you can find it.
Otherwise, good luck and I hope there is
a pain free future ahead for you.
God Bless.
Marie B.
|
jerseyboy
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Feb 2008 Posts: 17
Carrianne Posted: 02-06-08 12:55pm
Carrianne thank you for your offer, I'm
going to take you up on it.My appointment
at Bonati is 9 am feb 11. They told me
there would be 2 days of tests medical
clearence on the 3rd. day, surgery on the
4th day and post op and start therapy on
the 5th day. rest over the weekend,
therapy mon.&tues. surgery wed. and
start all over. Is that how it went for
you? Was there alot of waiting involved,
thats what I read.What was wrong with your
back and what they do for you? how was the
surgery? How long? How did you feel
afterward? How bad was the pain? Did it
help your pain right away did you notice
the difference? How was the therapy, They
told me to bring a bathing suit. Did they
give you excersises to do at home? Did you
go to therapy after you got home? How bad
was the pain when you left and how long
did it last.How restricted are you now in
the things that you do every day? I know
this is an awful lot of questions but in
case you can't tell I'm a total nervous
wreck.
Thank you for any help that you can give
me.
Jerseyboy
|
Carrianne
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Aug 2007 Posts: 107 Location: Tampa, FL
Re: Carrianne Posted: 02-07-08 09:00am
jerseyboy
wrote:
Carrianne thank you for your
offer, I'm going to take you up on it.My
appointment at Bonati is 9 am feb 11. They
told me there would be 2 days of tests
medical clearence on the 3rd. day, surgery
on the 4th day and post op and start
therapy on the 5th day. rest over the
weekend, therapy mon.&tues. surgery
wed. and start all over. Is that how it
went for you? Was there alot of waiting
involved, thats what I read.What was wrong
with your back and what they do for you?
how was the surgery? How long? How did you
feel afterward? How bad was the pain? Did
it help your pain right away did you
notice the difference? How was the
therapy, They told me to bring a bathing
suit. Did they give you excersises to do
at home? Did you go to therapy after you
got home? How bad was the pain when you
left and how long did it last.How
restricted are you now in the things that
you do every day? I know this is an awful
lot of questions but in case you can't
tell I'm a total nervous wreck.
Thank you for any help that you can give
me.
Jerseyboy
Jerseyboy,
Yes, the protocol was the same for me,
except I had a little time between my 2
days of tests, medical clearance, and
surgery since I live locally.
Yes, there was a bit of waiting. Bring a
book.
I have (all at L4/L5, L5/S1) DDD, bulge,
herniation, and one tear. They did partial
facetectomy, laminotomy, foramenotomy, and
discectomy on both discs (right side at
L5/S1 first, left side at L4/L5 second).
Surgery wasn't intolerable for me like
most people would expect(since you're
somewhat awake). When I felt something it
was like hitting my funny bone, but in my
leg and a little more intense. Nothing I
couldn't handle. I was actually watching
and asking the anesthesiologist questions
trying to learn! It took about an hour an
a half, but went by so much faster because
I was in and out of "sleep". I felt drowsy
afterwards and got sick once coming off
the anesthesia, but felt ok for the most
part. Surgical site wasn't very painful. I
iced a lot and took the pain meds as
needed(darvocet) for just a few days and
went off after. I'm not a medicine person.
I can't say I noticed a difference right
away because my pain was intermittent to
begin with, felt when sitting too long,
bending or twisting, etc. 6 months out, I
definitely feel better than I did before
surgery. At times I get discouraged
because the recovery has been much slower
than I wanted, but I sure didn't get that
way overnight so I can't expect an
overnight recovery.
I started physical therapy the day after
my surgery and went for 4 consecutive
days, 2 in the therapy center and 2 in the
pool. Yes, they gave me exercises to do at
home. Even better, they gave my physical
therapist at home (Tampa) a script to
follow for when I came home. I did PT at
home for 1 week and then had my second
surgery.
I had a complication with my second
surgery (dura leak) which set my recovery
back somewhat. I didn't start physical
therapy until 3 months after my second
surgery so am in it now 3 days a week for
2 hours each time. And I do my exercises
at home on the other days, along with an
hour of cardio 7 days a week.
I don't regret chosing this facility for
my surgeries and I felt honored to be Dr.
Bonati's patient. I have heard and read
all the criticism, but when it came down
to it I had to go with my "gut" and my gut
told me I was in the right place for me.
All the overcharging "charges" didn't
affect me because they honor
out-of-network benefits which I am blessed
to have. And the "charges" for unnecessary
surgery I must disagree with as well. He
did the first one and wanted me to wait 6
months before thinking about having
another. But when I proceeded to tell him
the symptoms I still felt he agreed it
best to do the next sooner than 6 months.
He was very honest with me and I learned a
lot from him and his team.
Hope this helps and sorry for the length!
Best wishes to you and God bless,
Carrianne
Thank you so much for answering my
questions. It's been a big help hearing
from someone who has had surgery at
Bonati. Now at least I know a bit more of
what to expect. I'm sorry to hear that
you had a problem with your second
surgery. I think I read somewhere on this
site that that can happen with open back
surgery too. It sounds like you had a lot
done in two surgeries. I guess they do
all they can when they make the incision.
YOu're lucky that you live close by and
you can take a break between surgeries.
That's one of my worries. My surgeries
are scheduled six days apart. I won't
know what to expect until they do the
test. What type of test did they do on
you? Is it just x-rays and MRI's or did
they do something else?
When you say that your recovery has been
slow, do you mean from the surgery itself
or the way that your pain has been
subsiding? Does the surgery site itself
take a long time to heal?
I will be flying back three days after my
last surgery. But if they can take away
some of this pain in my leg, I don't think
a few holes in my back will be too bad.
I've been living with this pain for many
years now and if they can just get rid of
60% or 70% of it, I'll be happy.
As far as their charges go, they gave me a
price for the first surgery and each
additional one. They said that everything
was included. I hope that doesn't change
when I get there.
They contacted my wife's insurance company
and they said they would accept what they
pay. I sure hope that I don't have any
problems with this. They gave it to me in
writing, but I also to agree to pay in
full, if the insurance company doesn't.
Carrie, I too have read all of the
articles, bad and good, and there are some
good ones. I think we all take a chance
no matter which way we do it, and this is
the way I'm doing it.
Thank you for all your help. I hope I'm
not bothering you too much.
|
jerseyboy
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Feb 2008 Posts: 17
Carrianne. Posted: 02-07-08 17:05pm
I guess that you can tell by my post that
I don't do this very often.
Thanks
again Jerseyboy
|
Carrianne
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Aug 2007 Posts: 107 Location: Tampa, FL
Posted: 02-08-08 10:36am
Jerseyboy,
I'm glad to offer my experiences to you
and hope that it helps you in some way.
When I say recovery hasn't been as quick
as I'd like I mean my back and leg pain.
Don't get me wrong, I've come a very long
way from where I was. I just have a ways
to go still which will take time. The
surgery site itself healed very quickly. I
have two 1-inch scars and that's about it.
They were swollen at first, but ice helps
a whole lot.
As far as the tests go, they did x-rays,
MRIs, nerve conduction, and a medical
clearance before the surgeries.
I do realize how blessed I am to be so
close (1 hr. drive from Tampa). Even more
blessed that my husband's uncle lives
right down the street so we were able to
stay with him which definitely helped us
financially.
I had the same uneasiness about the
charges, as far as balance billing goes,
but they held very true to their word. As
long as my insur. paid something, Bonati
wrote off the rest. There were only 3
charges that BCBS wouldn't pay for which
was then turned over to me. And I must say
that Bonati was extremely helpful in
reducing the cost by 50% if I could pay in
full. That saved me a few hundred dollars
so we were very pleased.
Please, if you have any other questions,
don't hesitate to ask. You're not
bothering me at all! I'd love to help in
any way I can.
Take care and God bless,
Carrianne
|
jerseyboy
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Feb 2008 Posts: 17
Carrianne Posted: 02-08-08 12:48pm
I can't express how much your posts have
helped. I can't thank you enough. I have
two more days before I leave and I am
really getting more nervous by the minute.
I went back to some of your posts after
you had your surgery and saw that you were
able to do a lot of walking. That's
great. EVerything that I read about laser
surgery seems to say that walking is very
important. I haven't been able to walk
100 yards in the past seven years. I hope
that I will be able to now. I'm looking
forward to it.
The thing that really scares me is that I
have so much wrong with my back. I have
severe stenosis at four levels. The way
that the pain is in my left hip and leg
makes me think that L4/L5 is where they
should start, but that will be up to
them.
Carrie, I forgot to ask you, did they give
you any kind of steroid injections? I
hope not, because like a lot of people
have said, if they do, how would you know
what's making you feel better?
I am so glad that I found this site. It
really is quite helpful. Again, thanks so
much.
Jersey Boy
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 910
Thanks: 21
Thanked:0
Posted: 02-08-08 23:40pm
Hello Jerseyboy,
You have done your research well. I hope
and pray that your surgeries in March go
well and likwise your recoveries.
My thoughts and prayers will be with you
on the 11th.
RichT
|
jerseyboy
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 04 Feb 2008 Posts: 17
Rich T Posted: 02-09-08 09:37am
Hello Rich T
Thank you very much. This site is great
I'm so glad that I found it, it has been a
great help to me , especialy Carrianne. I
will be leaving for Fl tomorrow, my first
appointment with Bonati mon. 9:00 am.
Surgery scheduled for thurs. I should be
able to post sometime after it as my
daughter will be down for a couple of days
and she has a laptop. Thanks again
everyone.
Jerseyboy
|
jimare
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 01 Oct 2007 Posts: 43 Location: ,
RichT Posted: 02-09-08 22:49pm
Somehow I lost the spinehealth address
"Laser Surgery II" Would you mind giving
it to me again so I can contact isis188.
Appreciate your help.
Will fill you in on my surgery at LSI at
a later date
Mare
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 910
Thanks: 21
Thanked:0
Issi Posted: 02-10-08 03:04am
Hello Mare,
I hope your surgery went well.
I'll send the link sometime today by PM.
The ole back is giving me a problem.
Thoughts and prayers to you.
RichT
|
jimare
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 01 Oct 2007 Posts: 43 Location: ,
still searching Posted: 02-10-08 21:32pm
Does anyone have the link for the other
forum on Laser Spine Surgery II
I tried looking for it but am having no
luck....lost track of isis188 and some of
the others on that forum.
Mare
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 910
Thanks: 21
Thanked:0
Posted: 02-10-08 22:00pm
Hello Mare,
I will send you a PM.
RichT
|
Carrianne
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Aug 2007 Posts: 107 Location: Tampa, FL
Posted: 02-11-08 09:35am
Jerseyboy,
All our thoughts and prayers are with you
today as you complete all your tests. Ask
as many questions as you can think of,
especially about having L4/L5 done first.
If it's in your head, it's worth asking!
I had an epidural steroid injection after
my first surgery, but not my second
because of the dura leak.
Best wishes to you and God's blessings!!!
Carrianne
|
Marie B.
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 28 Aug 2007 Posts: 231 Location: Ohio
Released By My Surgeon Posted: 02-11-08 14:42pm
Hi Everybody, I'm 12 and one half weeks
post op. Minimally Invasive Spine
Surgery: Incision 3"; Laminectomy
L4&L5, Foraminotomies left and right L
4 & L5 & S1. Decourtment of Facet
joints L4 &L5.
Removal of one and one half inches of
overgrown ligamentum Flavum L4 and portion
of L5. Fusion Insitu L4&L5 with use
of protein matter for encouraging bone
growth and resisting scar tissue. There
were other areas of small disc herniations
and very mild stenosis in the Thoracic
region that were not causing me pain nor
held any threats for the future as seen in
my MRI
Saw my surgeon this morning. Prayed all
the way to Cleveland Clinic because here
in Ohio, we just had a couple of days of
snow dumping and freezing temperatures.
What was an hour and 15 min. trip took
almost two hours because of the slow
traffic and slippery roads going into the
city.
Dr. McClain showed me my final X-rays that
were taken this AM prior to seeing him.
"He said, "Spine is now in good alignment,
everything is in its place, decompression
is complete and fusion insitu is adhering
very well, and he was as happy as I was.
We both had big smiles on our faces.
I told him that I had been saying how
grateful I was that he had been the doctor
I had chosen and that I had told everyone
that I wanted to give him a hug for
helping me become pain free. And you
know what? He held out his arms and I
gave him a big hug and he hugged me too,
saying "It was your positive attitude that
you were going to cooperate by obeying all
of the restrictions and followed through
with your desire that you did not want to
be on drugs for the rest of your life that
made you feel as well as you do today."
He said he would release me under certain
conditions...."no skiing, ice skating or
bob sledding....no parachute jumping,
rodeo riding or gymnastics and definitely
no lifting any weight over 25 lbs for
someone who is 5ft tall and weighing in at
110."... plus an ounce or two and
age....(two years younger then Rich T).
I hope my type spinal surgery and
providing all with my information and
experiences of this frightening and scarey
type surgery has helped others make their
decision to proceed with spinal surgery a
little more easy. I have said on more
then one occasion as I was recouperating
that I am glad I made this decision to
have the surgery that I needed at this
time.
If there is anything that I wish for all
who post on the spinal Forums, is that
they find a truly good doctor, have
successful surgery and live a pain free,
drug absent future.
Good Luck and God Bless all of you!
Marie B.
|
RichT
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Jul 2007 Posts: 910
Thanks: 21
Thanked:0
THANK YOU!! Posted: 02-11-08 20:10pm
Hello Marie,
Your prayers helped for a safe drive to
the clinic. So GREAT to know that your
recovery is going so very well.
Marie, thanks so very much for all you
have shared with us. From the details of
your surgery. To the hugs with your
surgeon, to your doctor's commending you
on following his advice to a "T", to your
thoughts of wisdom.
Without a doubt you made the right
decision for yourself. And as your doc
indicated, YOU were a major player in your
success. Marie, you are a SUPERB example
for all of us to look up to.
WHY is it that it seems all the SUPER
spine docs practice away from Wash. DC!!!?
You have a super doc in Cleveland, and
Fran has her super doc in Boston. All I
want is a doc who will take the time to
"hear" my 2-3 pages of questions and
EXPLAIN things to me.