Did you go to the doctor with her? This all sounds highly suspicious. Did she visit the doctor when her stomach started hurting and she began bleeding? Whenever miscarriage is suspected the woman NEEDS to go see the doctor.

Generally your body will hold onto the pregnancy hormones for a week or two. A pregnancy test will get lighter and lighter as time goes by.

Another thing, generally you get a prescription for pre-natal vitamins. Doctor's don't generally hand them out. She should have also had a 'pregnancy confirmation' note from her doctor.

These are all common things.


Wear condoms if you want to prevent this kind of thing from happening in the future! Good luck!

I went with to Dr. with her the first time, when we "confirmed" she was pregnant, but I didnt go into the room with her. However I was there when she walked out with practically a shopping bag of pre-natal vitamins (5 day samples, including Primacare ONE). It seemed fishy to me, I just want to know if its possible for this to have occured. Seems like alot of trouble to have gone through to lie, especially the part where she had to tell her parents. It doesnt make sense to me...

I'm curious, actually, why you would post this question on a message board... obviously this is nagging at you in some way. To sign up for a message board just to post your questions about the person you plan to spend your life with.

Why didn't you go into the doctor's office with her? Many fathers go to the first pre natal appointment. Did she get an ultrasound? When was her next appointment date? Generally women schedule their next appointment right then and there for, usually, 4 weeks from then.

Another thing I'm curious about... why when she started 'miscarrying', did the 2 of you go get another pregnancy test? Why not go back to the doctor? In the case of miscarriage - sometimes they get very severe. A woman can bleed to death if surgery isn't done. In fact, if there is prolonged bleeding at all, the doctor will do a D & C to remove any tissue that hasn't yet come out. This is a necessary procedure. A simple home pregnancy test doesn't do this.

I dont have the answers to these questions. Honestly Im pretty new to all this, I just want to know if its possible. She was about 10 weeks, and was spotting for about 2-3 days, then we took the pregnancy test. I'd just like to know if this is possible.

It is unlikely. Take her to the doctor because she needs medical attention - especially if the spotting was 1 or 2 days. Spotting in early pregnancy can be very common. But coupled with the negative pregnancy test, you should be concerned. She maybe be pregnant. It may be a 'missed' miscarriage. In which case she needs to see a doctor!

No. You don't have to answer any of my questions. But you already were thinking these things or you wouldn't have come and asked in an environment where no one knows you.

Good luck!

We dont live together, actually we live kinda far away, so its impossible for me to go with her to the doctor. However, she did say that she went to the Dr. the next day after the "miscarriage" and he said she had had a miscarriage, and that everything was passing on its own and she would be ok.

Now you say unlikely, but that still means its possible right?

i dont think her test would come back negative would it? if she misscarried wouldnt there be hormones still?

You obviously have doubts as the credibility of her story or you wouldn't have put miscarriage in quotation marks.

It normally takes a minimum of two blood tests to verify a miscarriage. And a few follow ups to check hormone levels. The doctor needs to confirm that the hcg is out of her system.

Would she have a reason to lie about this?

Listen to your heart. It is telling you something or you wouldn't be asking.

I will tell you this: when you are 10 weeks pregnant, you do not spot for 1 or 2 days and have a negative pregnancy test. You would BLEED a lot. And it would hurt badly. Not only that, but you would be terrified of what was happening.

Who is paying the doctor's bills? (you don't have to TELL me) Maybe, if you were paying them, you might see what they had to say.

I dont think she would have a reason to lie, but since when does that matter?

Yes. There can be hormones in your body for weeks afterwards that cause home pregnancy tests to come back positive.

Do you mean she has lied before without a reason? Or that people in general don't need a reason to lie?

im sorry but im pretty sure shes lying to you

i dont know why she would
maybe to stress you out? i dunno girls can be wierd

Apparently he thinks something in her story isn't adding up right.



Yankeeguy, we all know our own truths if we listen hard enough. Just as you felt the need to ask anonymously on a message board if this is possible... you know in your heart what the answers are already.

I will tell you this. When I went to the doctor initialy because my husband and I decided to start trying to conceive. I was given a 7 day trial of Primacare (not One) and a prescription for 12 months worth. So, please do not let the fact that she had prenatal vitamins sway your opinion. Prenatal vitamins are not ONLY prescribed to pregnant women.

I had a miscarriage at 6 weeks and i had to go for blood work for 3 weeks to make sure my numbers where dropping. at 3 weeks i still had hormones in me my number was low but it still showed. So i think when she took a test 3 days after the bleeding started it still would have showed positive

i dont think she told u the truth in the first place

i dont think shes pregnant at all
its trickery i tell you!

FISHY! The hormones remian in your body for weeks after a miscarriage, abortion or birth...Something is up here!

every time i've miscarried i had to go to the hospital so i wouldnt know if just a little spotting would provide a negative test. i do know that once u do start bleeding and it is confirmed that your going to have a miscarriage that you dont actually have one until your hcg levels drop below 50. but at six weeks that could happen in a couple of days.