Doctor Wants to Put Me On Anxiety Meds Posted: 12-29-07 00:15am
I've been having breathing problems for
the past six or so months. I've also
recently had a methacholine test that
showed I do not have asthma...which I
could have probably guessed myself since
the albuterol I was prescribed three or
four months ago never helped me.
Now my doctor - a family practice doctor -
is suggesting that if asthma is not the
problem then it must be a mental issue,
and he is suggesting putting me on
anti-anxiety medication. The thing is I am
as far from anxious as possible; even when
I should be stressed, I don't get so. I
remain very mellow in spite of everything.
What my doctor doesn't seem to realize is
I am not short of breath because of
anxiety - I am anxious because I'm short
of breath. I have had one major episode in
the past three months where I could not
breathe, but it resolved on its own.
I don't think I have anxiety, and I would
like to rule out physical problems before
medicating my brain (I want to keep my
insanity - as an art student, it is
crucial to my future to remain crazy ).
Are breathing problems by themselves
indicative of anxiety? Why jump
immeidately to that conclusion?
I'm sorry if this is a little
inappropriate for this forum - I no longer
see the general health forum here and I
didn't know if this belonged in anxiety or
asthma.
|
ladylee70
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 14 Nov 2006 Posts: 1912 Location: Boise, Idaho,
Thanks: 1
Thanked:0
Posted: 12-29-07 00:22am
Wow! Cambion, did your doctor give you a
full evaluation such as blood tests and a
possible echo (heart test)?? I would look
into possible heart issues. Seek out a
specialist such as an internal medical
doctor. I wouldn't want to go to a doctor
that thinks if you don't have asthma than
you must have anxiety or allergies without
looking into those other possible options.
Please, rule out all those other
possiblities first.
I suffer from pretty severe anxiety BUT
all of those other factors were completely
ruled out first. I was given a lot of
blood tests and an echo prior to being
prescribed anything. I was also given an
allergy test as well.
I hope you get some relief soon!! Please
keep us updated on how your are doing. My
best advice would be to seek out an
internal medical doctor. My experience is
that those doctors usually order a lot of
tests and have no problem referring to
appropriate specialists (i.e.,
cardiologist or allergy doctor) for
additional tests.
Karin
|
Cambion
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 08 Nov 2005 Posts: 738 Location: Earth
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0
Posted: 12-29-07 00:34am
Wouldn't I at least have a weird heartbeat
if it were heart-related? I've had my
pulse checked quite a bit since the
breathing issues started and no one has
ever expressed any concern that it might
be a heart problem. I should also add that
I had a CAT scan to rule out blood clots
in my lungs and the results came back
normal.
My mother has me on her insurance until I
graduate college, so she knows all these
problems I'm having and she said she also
had breathing problems when she was my
age. But hers went untreated and they
eventually resolved themselves. So that
gives me a little hope that maybe I have
something that is not serious.
ETA: I did a little research
on heart problems that are characterized
by breathing problems and a couple of the
symptoms I display are those of heart
failure, so now I think I am getting
anxious. But none of the
causes of heart failure really apply to me
- I've had my oxygen levels, heart rate
and blood pressure checked more than once
since this problem began and no one ever
expressed any concern that any of it was
abnormal (my oxygen levels were 98-99
percent at any given time). I know my BP
is slightly higher than the normal -
something like 123/80, so I can't imagine
that would constitute hypertension, and I
have never had heart problems before. It
can't be my age - I'm only 20 and there is
absolutely no history of heart problems in
my family. I also know I don't have
diabetes, arrhythmia, defective heart
valves, and so forth.
I was just thinking, though...if this was
something very bad, wouldn't it have
gotten worse over time and not better? My
breathing problems have gotten better
since they started. When I first had them,
I had chest tightness and pain, found
myself much more short of breath
(especially at night) and once or twice
felt my heart beating very hard, where I
could place a finger against my chest and
feel a noticeable hard thumping that was
my heart. I realize these are signs of
heart failure now. Since then, though, the
chest pain and the loud thumping have
stopped and now I have mild but constant
shortness of breath.
My problems are also not exacerbated by
physical exertion - I can walk five or
more miles in one day and then go home and
play DDR (if you don't know, it involves
lots of movement and is a good cardio
workout) and I won't feel anymore out of
breath than I did before I developed
breathing issues.
In fact, just today I played DDR and I
took less time to recover from the
exercise than I would have about a year
ago. Wouldn't a heart problem make it very
difficult for me to breathe following
physical activity? My problem is my
shortness of breath remains constant but
rarely worsens under any circumstances;
whether I am at rest or I'm walking,
jumping, or moving in general. When I went
through bouts of severe shortness of
breath, I was completely at rest. I was
sitting and trying to relax...and yet I
can walk six miles without resting and the
only pain I'll feel is in my legs and feet
(which is to be expected).
In any case, I will ask my doctor if he
thinks it may be a possible heart problem
because I don't want to have a heart
attack - not now, not ever.
|
Georgia59
Moderator
Joined: 11 Apr 2007 Posts: 5323 Location: Along the Mississippi, USA
Thanks: 65
Thanked:28
Posted: 12-29-07 11:45am
In my opinion, you should seek out the
advice of a psychiatrist before you go on
any psychiatric drugs. Well it could be a
symptom of anxiety, you shouldn't be on
drugs just because the doctor couldn't
find out what was wrong. And rule out any
other possible causes. I'm no expert on
heart conditions, but it seems worthwhile
to get that ruled out for sure.
The site is not a replacement for professional medical opinion, examination, diagnosis or treatment. Always seek the advice of your medical doctor or other qualified health professional before starting any new treatment or making any changes to existing treatment. Do not delay seeking or disregard medical advice based on information written by any author on this site. No health questions and information on eHealth Forum is regulated or evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration and therefore the information should not be used to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease without the supervision of a medical doctor. Posts made to these forums express the views and opinions of the author, and not the administrators, moderators, or editorial staff and hence eHealth Forum and its principals will accept no liabilities or responsibilities for the statements made.
Schizophreniahealth
This page was last updated on June 11, 2008