All Religious Prolifers, Explain This Posted: 12-07-04 11:37am
Hosea 9:11-16
"the glory of israel will fly away like a
bird, for your children will die at birth
or perish in the womb or never even be
conceived. Even if your children do
survive to grow up, I will take them from
you. It will be a terrible day when I
turn and leave you alone. I have
watched israel become as beautiful as
tyre. But now israel will bring out her
children to be slaughtered. O lord what
should I request for your people? I will
ask for wombs that don't give birth and
breasts that give no milk. The lord says
"all their wickedness began at gilgal;
there I began to hate them. I will drive
them from my land because of their evil
actions. I will love them no more
because all their leaders are rebels.
The people of israel are stricken. Their
roots are dried up; they will bear no
fruit. And if they give birth, I will
slaughter their beloved children."
numbers 31:17-19
" now kill all the boys and all the woman
who have slept with a man. Only the
young girls who are virgins may live; you
may keep them for yourselves"
hosea 13:16-
"the people of samaria must bear the
consequences of their guilt because they
rebelled against their god. They will be
killed by an invading army, their little
one's dashed to death against the ground,
their pregnant woman ripped open by
swords"
2 kings 13:16
"at that time menahem destroyed the town
of tappuah and all the surrounding
countryside as far as tirzah, because it's
citizens refused to surrender the town.
He killed the entire population and ripped
open the pregnant woman."
psalm 136:10
"give thanks to him who killed the
firstborn of egypt"
psalm 137:9
"happy is the one who takes your babies
and smashes them against the rocks!"
|
Moira
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 21 Nov 2004 Posts: 302 Location: somewhere where it rains a lot
Posted: 12-07-04 12:29pm
Also please explain why in no part of the
bible is a woman aborting condemned.
|
jenn_smithson
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 15 Nov 2004 Posts: 808 Location: Texas
Posted: 12-07-04 15:29pm
Also, please explain why in many parts of
the bible, advocating the death of fetus'
and children is exulted and praised.
|
bd1012
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 31 May 2004 Posts: 1998
Posted: 12-07-04 18:11pm
You successfuly evaded the answer.. If
your god is so prolife.. Than explain why
he kills children and the fetus all the
time.
|
Moira
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 21 Nov 2004 Posts: 302 Location: somewhere where it rains a lot
Posted: 12-07-04 18:29pm
jlee77
wrote:
again....Before anyone throws pebbles at
me, i'm asking you a question, not
accusing. From the comment above, are
you advocating m***er? Because it sure
sounds it. I understand you support a
woman's right to abort, you have made that
clear but please don't praise things such
as children being m*****ed.
no, she's asking for an explanation for
these events in the bible.
jlee
wrote:
why are you quoting the
bible , any of you....When you told izzy,
and me for that matter to keep religion
out of it????? That's not
right.
it's a seperate thread.
[quote"jlee"]moria:
i don't think abortion was a debate or
even a concept back then. [/quote]
you are joking aren't you? Or are you one
of those people who thinks abortion was
pretty much invented with rvw? Abortion
has existed waaay back in history -
hippocrates wrote it and he was way before
jesus. It was a concept. Now, if god has
such a big problem with it, why doesn't he
condemn it?
|
cphilyaw
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 24 Nov 2004 Posts: 95 Location: North Carolina
Posted: 12-07-04 19:01pm
I am not judging anyone but to those whom
think that jesus is okay with homicide is
wrong. Whether it be by a gun or a
scapel if you kill someone it it homicide
and to that it is a sin... I as well
think that you are taking the bible out of
context, those bible verses are not ment
to be thrown together with what ever verse
you want to put them with to make your
beleifs seems right, they are to be read
in the order they are written which makes
them fit into context with the writtings
and beliefs of jesus, god, lord all of the
above.. Personally I think you dont need
to be asking us about what the bible means
you need to seriously pray about it and it
will come to you when jesus wants it to be
revealed to you
|
bd1012
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 31 May 2004 Posts: 1998
Posted: 12-07-04 19:12pm
What do you mean they are taken out of
context? Can you read? It is word for
word straight out of the bible.. There
are diffrent versions of the bible so
yours may be diffrent but crack one open
and you'll see I took nothing out of
context. The verses are right there.
|
bd1012
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 31 May 2004 Posts: 1998
Posted: 12-07-04 19:18pm
cphilyaw
wrote:
i am not judging anyone but
to those whom think that jesus is okay
with not a nice act is wrong. Whether
it be by a gun or a scapel if you kill
someone it it not a nice act and to that
it is a sin... I as well think that you
are taking the bible out of context, those
bible verses are not ment to be thrown
together with what ever verse you want to
put them with to make your beleifs seems
right, they are to be read in the order
they are written which makes them fit into
context with the writtings and beliefs of
jesus, god, lord all of the above..
Personally I think you dont need to be
asking us about what the bible means you
need to seriously pray about it and it
will come to you when jesus wants it to be
revealed to
you
why don't you stop beating around the bush
and answer my freaking question! Yeah,
maybe the people whose children were
victim of god's slaughter weren't innocent
but why punish the child for the parents
sins? Isn't that why some of you
christians are against abortion even in
cases of rape? Because the "child"
shouldn't be punished for the sins of
their father? If your god is so prolife
then there is no excuse for killing
children at all, no matter what! Stop
making excuses and either explain your
god's motives or admit that he is not
prolife and has nothing against abortion
other than it @#$@ with his plans for that
will be child! I'll give you time to go
scurry to your pope and ask him how you
should explain that.
|
bd1012
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 31 May 2004 Posts: 1998
Posted: 12-07-04 20:59pm
"i wouldn't make fun of you if you told me
your religion."
oh so I guess I have to be religious in
order for you to not be rude.. I am not
the one constantly being condescending..
You are. No one wants to answer my
question because they don't have an
answer! There is no explanation but the
one they don't want to admit!
|
bd1012
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 31 May 2004 Posts: 1998
Posted: 12-07-04 21:17pm
What do you think it is smarty? Read the
post!
|
bd1012
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 31 May 2004 Posts: 1998
Posted: 12-07-04 21:35pm
Is it so hard to read? The freaking
question is for prolifers to explain how
someone prolife could do such a thing as
quoted above.. That's the question.
|
steen
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004 Posts: 1797 Location: Upper Midwest
Posted: 12-07-04 21:45pm
cphilyaw
wrote:
i am not judging anyone but
to those whom think that jesus is okay
with not a nice act is
wrong.
ah, because you say so,
right? Because you obviously speak for
jesus when the bible doesn't, right?
After all, how else would you know god's
will when the bible doesn't show it, and
on the other hand shows lots of examples
to the contrary, as bd's post showed?
Quote:
tr>
whether it be by
a gun or a scapel if you kill someone it
it not a nice act and to that it is a
sin...
the fetus is no more a
"someone" than a tumor or a hydatidiform
ole is. So exactly what sense does your
claim make, other than showing that you
are good at emotional postulations?
Quote:
tr>
i as well think
that you are taking the bible out of
context, those bible verses are not ment
to be thrown together with what ever verse
you want to put them with to make your
beleifs seems right, they are to be read
in the order they are written which makes
them fit into context with the writtings
and beliefs of jesus, god, lord all of the
above..
so, when god praises the
smashing of kids heads against rocks, that
is not really what god means?
Quote:
tr>
personally I
think you dont need to be asking us about
what the bible means you need to seriously
pray about it and it will come to you when
jesus wants it to be revealed to
you
jesus already did, having
shown me that he is pro-choice. So I
guess that settles it, then.
|
steen
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004 Posts: 1797 Location: Upper Midwest
Posted: 12-07-04 21:49pm
bd1012
wrote:
is it so hard to read?
The freaking question is for prolifers to
explain how someone prolife could do such
a thing as quoted above.. That's the
question.
lol. Bd, you might as
well give up. Pro-lifers never admits to
anything. Thats a cardinal rule of
theirs, as the moment they admit anything
about god not being 100% for all fetuses
that have ever existed, they feel their
argument and their faith is in danger.
That, of course, will condemn them to
hell, so because their "faith" is based on
fear, it doesn't matter what reality is.
Now, the rest of us christians, whose
faith is based on love for jesus are not
as hampered and we can trust that god
won't lie to us and will show is the
truth. Much better way to live, in my
opinion. I enjoy a much more rich
relationship to god than those whose
relationship is based on fear.
In that, I truly pitty the pro-lifers.
|
jenn_smithson
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 15 Nov 2004 Posts: 808 Location: Texas
Posted: 12-07-04 23:31pm
jlee77
wrote:
but I have a question for
jenn:
"also, please explain why in many parts of
the bible, advocating the death of fetus'
and children is exulted and praised. "
again....Before anyone throws pebbles at
me, i'm asking you a question, not
accusing. From the comment above, are
you advocating
m***er?
never would I advocate
homicide at all. I believe the question
which started this thread was "religious
pro-lifers, please explain". I therefore
assumed that people who use religion to
support their pro-life arguments would be
able to answer my question.
Quote:
tr>
because it
sure sounds it. I understand you
support a woman's right to abort, you have
made that clear but please don't praise
things such as children being
m*****ed.
first, I have never and
will never praise children being murdered.
However, there are many, many instances
in the bible where it has been advocated.
God "himself", in the bible, has
advocated the death and destruction of the
"unborn" and of children. Especially in
the old testament. Secondly, given this
truth, if one is to use religion as the
justification for their arguments, how do
they explain that the bible, especially in
the old testament, advocates the deaths of
fetus' and children. I am wondering how
someone who uses religion as their
justification for their arguments can
explain why they are using the bible to
support their argument when the bible
advocates the destruction of the very
"lives" they are claiming to want to save.
Quote:
tr>
why are you
quoting the bible , any of you....When you
told izzy, and me for that matter to keep
religion out of it????? That's not
right.
as this thread was
started to ask about religion with regards
to the abortion issue, please feel free to
comment. This *is* the debate forum so
we can bring up controversial topics for
discussion. Religion is just one of
these topics. Also, we asked you to keep
religion out of a place where it did not
belong. As this thread was started with
the specific intention of discussion
religious issues, it does belong here.
|
steen
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Nov 2004 Posts: 1797 Location: Upper Midwest
Posted: 12-08-04 01:43am
jlee77
wrote:
oh, and you can waste your
time replying, but your better off raging
on in some other thread with people that
care about what you have to say. I'm
sure you will find some other "pro-lifer"
to pick on. I'm only sorry I wasted so
much time on your ignorance...And I
emphasize ignorance. Merry x-mas!!!!!
Oops....Am I allowed to say that here?
rotflmao. Once you were
put on the actual spot, the tail goes down
between your legs and you slink off with
false bravado. How lame.
|
Izzy
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004 Posts: 883 Location: Earth
Posted: 12-08-04 05:51am
Double post
Last edited by Izzy on 12-08-04 06:00am; edited 1 time in total
|
Izzy
Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 16 Oct 2004 Posts: 883 Location: Earth
Posted: 12-08-04 06:00am
Ok I will take what you wrote.
1st
"the glory of israel will fly away like a
bird, for your children will die at birth
or perish in the womb or never even be
conceived."
now does this sound as though it is going
to be a good thing or a bad thing
according to god?
"even if your children do survive to grow
up, I will take them from you.
It will be a terrible day when I turn and
leave you alone. I have watched israel
become as beautiful as tyre. But now
israel will bring out her children to be
slaughtered."
well here it sounds as though abortion and
infantacide was rife in judea durring
these days.
"o lord what should I request for your
people? I will ask for wombs that don't
give birth and breasts that give no milk.
"
it seems to me that isreal found that
children were not convienient.
The lord says "all their wickedness began
at gilgal; there I began to hate them. I
will drive them from my land because of
their evil actions. I will love them no
more because all their leaders are rebels.
The people of israel are stricken.
Their roots are dried up; they will bear
no fruit. And if they give birth, I will
slaughter their beloved children."
it seems god has decided.... Hmmm if
they are going to kill the children I have
chosen to send them... When they choose
which children to love, I will make them
die.
Numbers 31:17-19
"now kill all the boys and all the woman
who have slept with a man. Only the
young girls who are virgins may live; you
may keep them for yourselves"
well this shows how god hates
homosexuality, sexual promiscutity and
hails the virtues of remaining chaste...
And how gods society should not accept
homosexuality and sexual promiscuity.
Hosea 13:16-
"the people of samaria must bear the
consequences of their guilt because they
rebelled against their god. They will be
killed by an invading army, their little
one's dashed to death against the ground,
their pregnant woman ripped open by
swords"
all sin carrys consiquences..... This is
a prophesy of an invaiding army but again
"little ones dashed to death" and
"pregnant woman ripped open by swords"
dosnt exactly seem to me to be a prophesy
of a good thing.
2 kings 13:16
"at that time menahem destroyed the town
of tappuah and all the surrounding
countryside as far as tirzah, because it's
citizens refused to surrender the town.
He killed the entire population and ripped
open the pregnant woman."
again this is not a good thing, being
destroyed, killed and pregnant women being
slaughtered along with there child... Is
a punishment not a reward!
If you want to be destroyed, killed and
slaughtered then sinning against god seems
to me to be a way of achieveing that.
"psalm 136:10
"give thanks to him who killed the
firstborn of egypt"
egypt had sinned against god by enslaving
his people, he did not kill the first born
of his own people but those who had sinned
against him and his chosen people....
Thus again he punishes egypt.... He is
not condoning but punishing!
Psalm 137:9
"happy is the one who takes your babies
and smashes them against the rocks!"
this should be taken in its full context
of
psalm 137:
remember, lord, [what] the edomites said
that day at jerusalem:
";destroy it! Destroy it
down to its foundations!"; 8 daughter
babylon, doomed to destruction,
happy is the one who pays you back
what you have done to us. 9 happy is he
who takes your little ones
and dashes them against the rocks."
i want us to see the history behind what
is going on here. And if you could try
and picture it for a moment in your mind -
if you can close your eyes it might help
you to try and picture the scene that is
before us. And what we can see by our
mind's eye is an army round about
jerusalem, soldiers gathering around its
walls, and they are plundering the walls,
they have come into the city, there is
fire, there is smoke rising from the midst
of it, they are slaying the people, there
is rape, there is pillage, the city is
burning in embers. But we see something
else, because within the city and around
the city we see a group of people that are
not being harmed. We see a group of
neighbouring people, citizens who are
called the edomites. And as the children
of judah, as their flesh burns, as the cry
of the children comes out of the walls of
that city, as they're destroyed, as the
whole of the holy city is wrecked, this
nation, this people, these citizens the
edomites, are standing around idly by,
watching as it all goes on. But they're
doing more than that, they're not simply
passively standing by, but the word of god
would lead us to believe that they are
actually shouting, taunting, encouraging
the babylonians as they're sacking the
city, to burn the city, to destroy the
city, to do their worst to the city, to
leave not one rock or stone upon another,
not one jewish life alive. How do we
know that? If you were to go back to
psalm 137 and verses 7 to 9 you would hear
the cry of the edomites - picture them as
they stand round jerusalem, they're
shouting 'raze it! Raze it!', they're
calling, 'dash their little children
against the stones! Wipe them out, make
sure that not one jew survives!'.
Who are this people the edomites? My, if
we were to look and go into the history of
the word of god and find out who these
awful people, this treacherous cruel
people were, you know it would surprise
us. Because, believe it or not, the
edomites are the brothers of the judeans.
Those that are doing these terrible
things, these neighbours that are standing
round, they are the edomites, they are the
descendants, the word of god tells us, of
esau, jacob's older brother.
2nd
you are not god, you can not choose who
lives or dies.... It is a sin to do so,
for this is his domain not yours!
|
bd1012
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 31 May 2004 Posts: 1998
Posted: 12-08-04 10:41am
Izzy.. Why is he punishing people by
killing the children? I never saw
anything about where the children have
sinned! How would you have liked it if
you were killed because your mom was a
hooker? I don't care if it's a
punishment because he is punishing the
wrong people, and don't prolife people
against abortion in case of rape say "it's
wrong to kill the child for the sins of
their father". If he loved children so
much, he would punish the sinner and not
the children if children are supposed to
be so innocent.
|
cphilyaw
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 24 Nov 2004 Posts: 95 Location: North Carolina
Posted: 12-08-04 10:46am
First off if you have to come at me with
slander and critisism to justify or make
your point, beliefs, whatever they are
look better than mine because you cant
come up with something constructive you
need to go do a little more research on
"your facts", I dont have to go see and
ask my "people" I refer to the bible
itself, I said taking it out of context is
because you have taken 6 or more verses
and put them together to make it sound
like it is agreeing with you lets put the
verses before and after those verse
together and see how they sound...I am
reading out of the new kings james
versionn, references red letter edition
hosea 9 (headline is jedgement on israels
sin) 9: do not rejoice, o israek, with joy
like other peoples, for you have played
the harlot against you god you have made
love for hire on every threshing floor.
The threshing floor and the winepress
shall not feed them, and the new wine
shall fail in her, the shall not dwell in
the lord"s land, but ephraim shall return
to egypt, and shall eat unclean things in
assyria, they shall not offer wine
offerings to the lord, nor shall the
sacrifices be pleasing to him, it shall be
like bread of mourners to them ,all who
eat it shall be defiled, for their bread
shall be for their own life, it shall not
come into the house of the lord, what will
you do in the appointed day, and in the
day of the feast iof the lord? For indeed
they are gone because of the destruction.
Egypt shall gather them up memphis shall
bury them, nettles shall oposses their
valuables of silver, thorns shall be in
the tents, tyhe days of punishment have
come, the days ofrecompense have come,
isreal knows! The prophet is a fool, the
spritual man is insane, because if the
greatness of your iniquity and great
enmity, the watchman of ephraim is with my
god, but the prophet is a fowlers snare in
all his ways, enmity in the house of his
god, they are deeply corrupted, as in the
days of gibeath he wil remeber their
iniquity, he will punish their sins, I
found isreal like grapes in the
wilderness, I saw your fathers as the
firstfruitson the fig tree in its first
season, but they went to baal peor, and
seperated them selves to that shame, they
became an abomination like the things they
loves, as for ephraim their glory shall
fly away like a bird, no birth, no
pregnancy, no conception! Thought hey
bring up their children yet I will bereave
them to the last man, yes , woe to them
when I depart from them, just as I saw
ephraim like tyre, planted in a pleasent
place, so ephraim will bring out his
children to the mirder, give them . O
lord, what will you give? Give them a
miscarrying womb and dry breast! All
their wickedness is in gilgal, for there I
hated them because of the evil of their
deeds, I will drive them from my house I
will love them nomore all their princes
are rebellious ephraim is stricken their
root is dried up they shall bear no
fruit,, yes were they to bear children I
would kill the darlings of their womb my
god will cast them away beacuse the did
not obey him, and they shall be wanderers
of the nations.
That kinda puts a different look into
things if you read what goes along with it
instead of the verse you need to justify
your "?", thats what is mean by taking it
out of context you pulled one verse out of
17 verses that make that one
|
bd1012
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 31 May 2004 Posts: 1998
Posted: 12-08-04 10:49am
You are not listening to me..I realize the
people of the town have sinned but why are
they taking it out on the children?
Miscarrying wombs? He is purposefuly
giving them miscarriages.. And
intentional miscarriage is what? Say it
with me.. Abortion. If the fetus is so
innocent why is he taking his anger out on
it?