I think the wic is a great program and so
it welfare..But..I just persaonlly do
think its fair to those of us who work and
pay for other peoples kids. It would be
another story if for example both parents
work but they cannot make enough to
support their child that they have. Then
yes, I would gladly say that being on wic
or welfare is good. But for those that
want to stay home and want more children
although they clearly canoot support them
is ridiculous. I would gladly love to
stay home right now.. But I can't. Have
you tried being pregnant.. Working 50
hours a week and going to college taking
16 credits a term? Now thats tough... I
would quit my job in a heartbeat and live
off of welfare.. But I go to work and
will continue to work even after my baby
is born. Yes, I would love to stay home
and take care of my baby.. But have
respect for the governments tax money and
want to personally take care of my
responsbility....
Im not trying to rank on anyone I
promise.. Its just these programs are
abused and im sick of having $300 taken
out of my paycheck to pay for someones
baby whos mother can get a job.. Thats my
opinion..
|
babymamahr01
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Nov 2004 Posts: 52 Location: WI
Posted: 03-14-05 13:30pm
First of all I have worked and gone to
college while I was pregnant ..... And
the whole debate about tax money...Well my
soon to be husband works a full time job
and about 10-15 hrs a week overtime so his
money would just be coming back to us
anyway...You act like we both don't have
jobs and want to live off welfare forever.
I don't even know if I could get the 700
for 3 mo. If I can good...If not oh
well. We are already looking at moving
into a 3 bedroom apt which arounf here
costs about 650 a mo. But we are not
getting housing assistance. We buy our
own food...Pay to do our laundry...Etc.
All I would be getting from the gov't is
formula and med assistance which my soon
to be husband has insurance so ot would
only be covering the remaining 20
perecent. Also why have a child if you
have to have someone else raise your
child. I love being a stay at home
mom.....There are plenty moms who
are....Cause I know my child is safe and
loved. I just don't see a point in
poping out children to fill the daycares
which btw around here run close to 300 a
week. Maybe those who disagree with me
don't yet have a child and don't realize
how much they cost!!! I will do what I
need to to take care of any children I
have and I don't think what I am doing is
wrong unless caring for and loving my
child is wrong! :!: :!: :!:
|
2ferano
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Dec 2003 Posts: 3717
Posted: 03-15-05 14:19pm
Yeah, sorry girls but I agree with the
first couple of replies.
No, I don't have a problem with a woman
who has a child or has one on the way
using wic and medicaid for their child!
But I do have a big problem with someone
trying to conceive knowing that they can't
afford the baby. Yes, there is something
wrong with that. When you are going to
try to have a baby, ya know, make it
happen on purpose then be ready!
Financially and emotionally and every
other way possible. Don't just say, "oh,
well, I can't afford to get pregnant, but
I am going to anyway because of
wic,medicaid etc." those programs are made
for people who get pregnant and cannot
afford it, but it isn't there to promote
people getting pregnant because the
government will just pay for it.
I hate to sound cruel, but I was raised to
hold my own! I was raised to marry for
love, get financially stable enough and
then if I want kids to have them. Now,
no, I am not saying I am perfect, and I
could have ended up pregnant and
definately not in this order! But, what
I am saying is that if you really want a
baby, then do what is right for the
baby!
I don't think I would have very much
respect for my parents if they had
purposely gotten pregnant knowing the
government would support me.
|
babymamahr01
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Nov 2004 Posts: 52 Location: WI
Posted: 03-15-05 19:03pm
Funny...The only one's who put me down are
barly old enought to be called adults and
even some who aren't legal age
yet.......
To all who put me down....
Grow up !!!!!!!!!!!!!
|
2ferano
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Dec 2003 Posts: 3717
Posted: 03-15-05 19:25pm
I should grow up? Honey, you have no
idea how old I am then apparently. And,
what is the point of having children for
someone else to raise them? First of all
daycare doesn't raise children. Daycare
cares for your children while you and your
husband, or you and the father of your
child or just you are out "working" to
support you child! Would I want to put
my child in daycare? Ideally know, but
then again I am not out trying to get
pregnant either.
And just because your husband works 40
hours a week plus 10-15 hours of overtime
doesn't mean that it is just "your money
coming back to you." that is crap and you
know it. You already would get your
money back in your tax returns for your
children then on top of that you are
getting medical assistance and wic. So,
no, the other taxpayers are in a way, not
fully, but in a way supporting you.
And if your husband works 50-55 hours a
week, don't you want to wait until he
would be able to spend more time with your
child? Let's say he works afternoons,
okay fine, then why don't you work
daylight or midnight to earn extra money
and not collect wic and medical
assistance? If your husband is getting
insurance soon, then why not wait?
Like I said if you were already pregnant
it would be a different story, but you are
trying to act like you have everything
worked out, but if it was all worked out
then it wouldn't include government
assistance.
And, no one is putting you down. You
asked for everyone's opinions and you are
getting them. Next time if you don't
want them then you shouldn't ask. Now,
you are getting all offended and trying to
act like what you are doing is right and
the rest of us need to grow up, when we
aren't the ones asking if we should try to
get pregnant and collect government
assistance.
There is nothing wrong with wanting babies
and there is nothing wrong with wanting to
stay home with your children. That is a
wonderful thing. But loving your
children starts before conception and you
have the option right now of waiting a
year or more or even less just to make
sure the baby would have the best life you
could possibly give it. So, if you truly
want to bring a child into this world and
love it and care for it the best you
possibly can, then just wait until things
settle a little. By the sounds of it you
don't have very far to go at all, so why
not just wait?
|
babymamahr01
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Nov 2004 Posts: 52 Location: WI
Posted: 03-15-05 22:18pm
So you don't want kids right now...Maybe I
do. Number 2 I didn't know everyone was
going to jump down my throught cause I
want a baby. All the other boards had
supporters who have done the same thing as
what I want to do. Number 3 you know
nothing about my taxes. My ex gets to
claim her and I don't see a cent of it so
there. That's how great the system
works...He never see's her....Don't pay
c.S. Half the time but gets to claim her!
And 4 hotasfrick you don't even know me
so shut your mouth!!!!!
|
Innchik18
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2004 Posts: 247 Location: Oregon
Posted: 03-16-05 11:46am
Arrrgghh..Will you get it through your
head that noone is saying its wrong for
you to want a child. Its natural
feeling.. Yeah babies are cute. But all
we're trying to say is that if you do not
have an extra $3,000 a year just laying
around then you should rethink it. I mean
you have so many options.. While ur
boyfriend is working right now and ur at
home why dont you go to college.. Or some
classes so you can get a part time job
working like 4 hours a day or so. Even
that will help.. Trust me. Its just the
way you came off was.. "oh I love being a
stay at home home and want more kids but
we cant afford to raise them.. But I
guess somehow things will work out, ill
get assistance or something"... Kids
require a lot more then what ur gonna get
from wic.. They eat more then milk,
cheese and cheerios. You have like a year
(if you are gonna get pregnant soon) in
front of you..Take advantage so that you
can help out will bills or food. Dont you
want to be independent and show your kids
that although it was a struggle.. But you
raised them to the best of your ability
and that you actually tried.....
Something is better than nothing at
all.... Just think of it that way.....
|
2ferano
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Dec 2003 Posts: 3717
Posted: 03-16-05 14:10pm
Well, for your information...Number 1: I
don't want children now, and you
do....Great....I didn't say that you
shouldn't want children...I said you
should wait until you could afford to
raise your own children instead of
depending on other people. (and yes,
government assistance is funded by other
people so technically other people are
paying to raise your child.) I don't know
anything about your taxes. I wasn't
talking about your other child! I was
talking about the one you are trying to
conceive and have the government pay for.
Those are the taxes that you said would
just be coming back to you, and I
explained that they aren't! Yes, your
"husband's" money is coming back to you,
but on top of that you will be getting
other people's tax money also. The
theory that when you collect government
assitance you are just getting your tax
money back is a uneducated theory because
that is not how it works.
Sorry that you thought you were going to
post here and have everyone say, "yeah, go
for it! Have another baby, maybe even 2
and let the tax payers pay for it!" you
asked if you should have a baby and you
are getting honest responses.
If you and your husband have everything
all worked out as you have previously
mentioned then why don't you wait until it
is all worked out. Even if I did want
kids now, I would know enough to wait
until I could raise them without
government assistance. I am mature and
educated and respect myself enough to not
take taxpayers money because I tried to
get pregnant knowing I couldn't afford it.
And I do know how the "system" works. I
know that the only way that your ex can
claim your daughter is if he has custody.
The person who pays child support cannot
write that off, the person who has
majority custody is the one who can claim
the child on taxes. So, if your ex
doesn't have custody and doesn't pay child
support then all you have to do is take it
to court and get the right to claim her on
your taxes. And I am sure there is some
way you can use taxpayer money to pay your
attorney.
I am not and have not tried to be rude to
you. I simply am stating my opinions
based on my values. Not everyone has the
same values as me and that is fine, but I
would never ever in a million years get
pregnant on purpose knowing that the
government support my child. That is
ignorant, immature and a very uneducated
way of living in my opinion. I was
raised better.
You don't need to get so defensive.
Being defensive is a sign that you were
proven wrong or that you don't have any
valid argument against a person. Don't
get upset. Try to explain without
insulting and telling me to "shut my
mouth" (also a sign that you have no valid
argument) why you should get pregnant on
purpose when you are not financially
ready. Why when you don't have very long
to wait for your husband to get health
insurance that it is a better idea to get
medical assistance from the government?
Why, if he is almost out of college, you
can't wait until he is? Why you can't
get a job opposite his hours? Why you
don't want to be independent and a good
role model for you baby?(instead of
raising the baby on government assistance
when you had other and better options)
|
Innchik18
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2004 Posts: 247 Location: Oregon
Posted: 03-17-05 13:15pm
Hotasfrick- wow ur good hehe....
But yeah we're honest girls here.. If you
ask us something.. We'll give it to you
straight up. Its tough love here
lol...We're not gonna tell you what you
wanna hear if it isnt right. You asked
us.. We answered in true honesty.. Sorry
if we came off strong.. But personally
for me its a touchy subject because I hate
taxes.. I hate that 1/3 of my pay check
that I earn goes to the government.. And
then the money sometimes goes to people
who should not be receiving it. Its a
messed up system and a messed up world we
live in... Hopefully everything turns out
for your and your family....
|
2ferano
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Dec 2003 Posts: 3717
Posted: 03-17-05 13:28pm
Thanks! U too!Lol!
I agree very much so. I get so tired of
hearing about new families and how hard it
is for new families to make it, so they
get the earned income credit, tax write
offs and all of these bills in progress to
give them special treatment. Yes, it is
very hard when you are starting out, but
just because you aren't married and don't
have kids doesn't mean you shouldn't get
any help, ya know? Don't get me wrong I
wouldn't accept government assistance
unless I was a mother and couldn't afford
to feed my child or if I was on the verge
of becoming homeless, but it angers me
off! On top of the 1/3 of our paycheck
going to people who make more money than
me, but chose to have a family when they
couldn't afford it, or to the people who
just don't want to work so they can stay
home with their kids (when they can't
afford it) or the people who just want to
collect disability for being lazy, they
charge extra on my phone bill for people
who cannot afford a phone! When I
couldn't afford a phone I didn't have one!
Plain and simple! And on the electric
bill, check here if you want to add blank
amount of dollars to your bill to help the
people who can't pay theirs! Urgh, they
are trying to make that mandatory also!
Go out and get a job! Get a second job,
or a third! That is what I have had to
do since I was on my own at a very young
age. I didn't decide to have a kid when
I couldn't afford it, even if I did want
to. I didn't apply for food stamps, I
went and got an other job.
So, yes, it makes me very, very angry that
I am taxed, charged extra and asked to
donate money to people when I am the one
working two or three jobs and can't make
ends meet. It just isn't right.
And I wouldn't mind so much if it went to
people who need it, but 99% of the time it
doesn't. It goes to people who had kids
on purpose when they knew they couldn't
afford it, went on disability just because
they are severly overweight (due to
overeating and no excercise whatsoever),
and others who just have a kid and decide
to work the system. An old friend of
mine (notice old) made more money than I
did, had her own trailer, and since she
had a son, collected energy assistance
(free heat and help with her electric
bill) and had the energy company come out
and do a test (if you qualify, have a kid,
they will give you new windows and doors
if any air whatsoever blows into them!,
hello, it's a trailer, the windows are
going to have air coming in
them!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! No one ever
bought me new windows! They will also
give you new appliances if the are over 3
years old!!!!!!!!). And she didn't need
it! It just makes me so mad! I can't
talk about it anymore!Haha.
|
Kiss_Me04
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Nov 2004 Posts: 158 Location: New York City
Posted: 03-17-05 13:49pm
Im 20 years old and 21 weeks pregnant and
have had a job since I was able to get
one.. Because something came up in my
pregnancy my doctor has stopped me from
working.. Now I know im not rich.. But
what about women who have reasons for not
being able to work.. Definitely after my
baby is born im going back to work.. But
what about now.. Are tax payers gonna be
mad because im unable to work... Im a
tax payer myself...
|
babymamahr01
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Nov 2004 Posts: 52 Location: WI
Posted: 03-17-05 14:34pm
Well, I told my parents and we told his
parents our plans on having another child.
We have located a really nice 3 bedroom
apt for only $20 more a mo then the 2
bedroom we are in. We also have 3 bins
of new baby clothes ( I buy them at the
huge end of season clearances stores
have....Carters and stuff for under 50
cents each) and a few bins of used
clothes. We have bottles and other baby
items as such. We are using our tax
return to get my daughter a nice twin size
bed and matching dresser and using the
rest to get a stroller/carseat, my dad
wants to buy a crib and matress, and his
parents want to get a changing table and
swing as soon as I get pregnant. I am
going to get the ma to help cover all
medical because I went to the doc to get a
pre pregnancy exam and was told I may need
a c-section if I have a baby cause I have
a tilted uterus and my stbh insurance
doesn't cover a very long hosptial stay.
We will be getting wic but my dad said
he'd help with some formula so any extra
we would get we would give back or donate
to someone who needs it. You know....The
gov't assistance is there to help people.
They don't ask questions they just help.
All who write they are against it would
take it in a heartbeat if they needed it
for there child. All i'm saying is I
want the best for my child. I want
another now cause there is ovarian cancer
in my family and if that happened to me I
coukldn't have more. We will make it
work.
|
Innchik18
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2004 Posts: 247 Location: Oregon
Posted: 03-17-05 16:08pm
Well then you made your decision... Not
much more any of us can add......
|
unbreakable88
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 30 Dec 2004 Posts: 14 Location: VA, USA
Posted: 03-17-05 19:31pm
Honestly...My mom had me at 18 and she got
some help from her parents yeah..We used
to live with them and such and when she
went on her own..Dunno what age and moved
in with my dads family she got that wic
and welfare stuff for me..And it wasnt
that my parents families wouldnt help take
care of me..It was that they wanted my
parents to learn responsibility and
such..Oh well I dunno..But yeah I mean it
helps alot of families and I was lucky to
have a mom who cared enough for me to say
she needed help and had to get all that
wic and welfare stuff just to make sure
i'd be happy and healthy.. Cos I mean we
we're not rich people..And not everyone
who sits on their ass all day who doesnt
work is just doing it to be lazy..Some
people actually cannot work, like my dad
couldnt work because of some health
issues that he has..And some people simply
just dont make enough money to support
their family on their own but that doesnt
mean they can't have kids just cos they
dont make enough money...Families with
even the most amount of money dont have
the best kids..Cos some grow up to be
spolied and such..And kids who grow up not
having alot tend to see and value things
that are most important anyways, so yeah
I dont see a problem with it if you are
absolutely ready to have kids..Cos at the
end of the day..Honestly none of us here
is gonna be living ur life and actually
know what its like so hey if ur ready for
having another kid and u got a good soon
to be husband who is willing to be there
and support u and such then I dont see a
problem with it at all
btw hope I made sense lol
|
babymamahr01
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Nov 2004 Posts: 52 Location: WI
Posted: 03-18-05 11:27am
I agree totally. I have a cousin who has
so much money and has a kid but doesn't
know at all how to take care of a baby,
she buys it everything but basic
care...She's clueless. I belive parents
who don't have as much money are able to
spend more time with there children (
especially stay at home moms) and those
children learn important values. The
world is about alot more than money!
|
2ferano
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Dec 2003 Posts: 3717
Posted: 03-18-05 15:06pm
Kiss me. No, I don't have a problem with
people using government assistance. I
have a problem with people who get
pregnant on purpose when they know they
can't afford it and then use assistance
when it all could have been avoided.
But, the world is made up of all kinds and
some people don't agree. That's fine.
Someday, there will be stricter limits on
these things and I for one can't wait!
But, good luck to everyone with whatever
they decide!
|
unbreakable88
New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 30 Dec 2004 Posts: 14 Location: VA, USA
Posted: 03-18-05 16:23pm
Hotasfrick..I can see where your comming
from so in that sense I guess i'm agreeing
with you also..Its really hard cos most of
the time I can see where most are comming
from so I can see both sides of
everything, like I can see how she wants
to have children and such but I also can
see how some people might not like that
peple are getting pregnant on purpose just
to have government funding...But I mean I
know its early to say this cos hell i'm
only 17 but those kids are gonna be the
ones taking care of our generation when we
get older, paying for our retirement funds
and such, so I guess its like u gotta give
alittle to get alittle I hope I dont get
attacked for this or whatever lol just
thats what I think
|
babymamahr01
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Nov 2004 Posts: 52 Location: WI
Posted: 03-19-05 19:48pm
I'm not getting pregnant just to use the
gov't assistance. Yeah...It will help
but i'm trying cause I love my daughter
and my fiancee and I want a child
together. I may be a stay home moom but
I take such good care of my little girl
and she is so smart and I belive kids just
do better being with there parents. I'm
even thinking of homeschooling her cause
she is so smart and I don't want her mixed
up with the wrong crowd. I love my
daughter and i'll love this baby and money
don't change that!
|
2ferano
Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 23 Dec 2003 Posts: 3717
Posted: 03-20-05 19:25pm
Well, I wouldn't suggest homeschooling
your daughter in grammar and spelling.
Unbreakable, I am not going to attack you!
I am not attacking anyone. I see where
you are coming from, but in my opinion, as
far as the you have to give a little to
get a little, we will be funding our own
retirement. Actually, by the time I
retire (i don't know about you) I am
betting their wont even be social security
and all of the money we all pay into it
now will be gone. Once again, because of
the people who collect it and don't need
it, and the government spending our
retirement security on other things
instead of what it is collected for.
I don't doubt that this lady loves her kid
and that she will love this one. But
love isn't all you need. You also need
parents who worked hard to take care of
you and raise you right, and not parents
who purposely conceived you knowing they
couldn't support you financially.
Yes, ideally children would have a parent
home with them in their first years
rearing them, but I have more respect for
the parent who will work to make sure
their child has what they need, before the
one who stays at home and collects
welfare. No one is saying you and your
husband both have to work the same shift
and put your children in daycare. Their
are several positions you could apply for
that would be the opposite shift and
therefore, one of you would always be with
your child. But, as I said before, some
people are selfish and will do what they
want regardless of what is right. That
is why are government is in such financial
trouble to begin with, selfishness and
laziness.
|
babymamahr01
Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 22 Nov 2004 Posts: 52 Location: WI
Posted: 03-20-05 20:48pm
I never said that I couldn't support my
children. I have already taken care of
the child I have on my own and I plan to
support my next child as well. So I want
some formula to care for it! Not
everyone is rich and I don't know where
you live but where I am there are no good
jobs. Every place is being closed down
and jobs are being sent overseas. Even
wal-mart isn't hiring. I do do childcare
from my place and as I have said my
fiancee is working as much as he can.
Someday you'll learn that no matter how
you would like life to go it doesn't
always work that way. Not everyone is
rich, not everyone has parents that will
pay for everything they want and not
everyone can land that perfect job! I
come from a hard working middle class
family that belives in spending time with
their family not being at work 24/7 !