Abortion Debate Forum - a Little History Lesson page 4
medical questions | health forums log in    

a Little History Lesson

New Topic  Reply  Ask A Doctor - Offline
Medical Questions-> Health Forums -> Abortion Debate -> a Little History Lesson
Author Message
Tazzy D

Advanced Support Team
Joined: 30 Oct 2004
Posts: 3718
Location: , va

Posted: 11-07-05 19:32pm

But it can also hurt a child.... There are some things you say and some things that you just dont tell your child... I agree to disagree .. So im to tell my child the reason why her twin died is because her father beat me? Not the reason I gave her... I dont believe this one..
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12984
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 11-07-05 20:22pm

tazzy d wrote:
eiri wrote:
tazzy d wrote:
stillmehere wrote:
tazzy d wrote:
and neither do you, but you proclaim that it is a womens right.. A womens right to what kill....


yup. Just as it is her right to eat killed animal meat. To kill bacteria and germs on her clothes/body. Her body, her right.



and it is our right to say that it is not healthy just like anything else..


it's your individual right to say that you dissaprove of it, but just as vegetarians can't enforce their beliefs upon america, neither can you.



why not it was forced upon mcdonalds


last time I checked, mcdonalds still sells real beef. With the vegetarians I meant that they can't force the whole nation to be totally vegetarian just cause they think eating meat is bad. And hey, if mcdonalds is going to get more customers because they have veggie burgers, isn't that a good thing for capitalism?

Just like for abortion. You can't force every woman who becomes pregnant to carry to full term.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12984
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 11-07-05 20:27pm

cowboys wrote:
eiri so for you to live another had to die and you think that is acceptable.I know I would not like to know that I was only born because of that.Do you think it was right for your mother to inform you off this.If your father is the man you say he is wouldn't he of taken on both of them.?


i do think it is acceptable, because that's what happened, and I can't change it. What, should I go commit suicide because my mother should never have had that abortion and thus I shouldn't exist?

My mother had an older brother, but he died as a baby 2 days after he was born. Because my grandma wanted 2 children, and already had one son, she tried again and gave birth to my mother. If that baby hadn't died, my mother wouldn't exist. Should she regret her very existance?


And... My mother never would have met my dad. I don't see very many pregnant 20 year olds joining sororities, and that's how my mom met my dad. She didn't get pregnant with my dad the first time, as I said. It was some other dude.

Ona final note, she told me this when I turned 20, and when I ws entering into a sexual relationship stage with my current bf. She just wanted to warn me about what could happen, etc, and to let me know she'd be there for me.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12984
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 11-08-05 00:15am

jlee77 wrote:
to say your mom would'nt be here or you wouldn't be here if this, and that.....You can't say that. You may have been. That is something you can't know. Plans don't always pan out, as we all know. (the reason so many selfish b**ches kill their children).



If you were to be born, you will be. (this goes for anyone).


if my mother never had sex with my father, then it would be impossible for me to be born. Duh. I was made because she had sex with my father at a specific time, when a specific egg ovulated and a specific sperm of his met with it. You change anything at all in the past, and those things don't happen. And it's not a child yet, it hasn't been born.

Are you going to touch on anything else I said or just ignore it?
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12984
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 11-08-05 11:59am

jlee77 wrote:
eiri wrote:
jlee77 wrote:
to say your mom would'nt be here or you wouldn't be here if this, and that.....You can't say that. You may have been. That is something you can't know. Plans don't always pan out, as we all know. (the reason so many selfish b**ches kill their children).

If you were to be born, you will be. (this goes for anyone).


if my mother never had sex with my father, then it would be impossible for me to be born. Duh. I was made because she had sex with my father at a specific time, when a specific egg ovulated and a specific sperm of his met with it. You change anything at all in the past, and those things don't happen. And it's not a child yet, it hasn't been born.

Are you going to touch on anything else I said or just ignore it?


what I was saying, (*.D. U.H!!) was that it was meant to be for your parents to do the bam bam and create you. What i'm attempting to explain to you may be too difficult or ellaborate for you to understand. You like to twist words and create different meanings for them anyways and I wish not to deal with your nonsense. This conversation is over .Ms. "i'm better than everyone else".

I picture you to be an annoying troll. No offense. You make yourself out to be that way.
When your ready to hear me out and stop shutting out my explanations as you accuse me of doing, let me know. Oh...And when your ready to stop insulting my intelligence as you have come so accustomed to doing in the other threads. So much for you being that "sweet, caring and innocent" girlie you claimed to be huh?


oh yes that's right, all things are "meant to be" because we have no real free will under .God. I never claimed to be sweet and innocent... I do recall saying I was kind and caring, but that I would also call out in debate anyone I thought was being less that smart in their posts. The problem is that you are only using religion as your soapbox for this argument, whereas I am using the morals I learned from religion and scientific logic.

You accuse me of being unethical, and a proponent of killing babies, but you constanly forget the fact that I don't consider a 4 month fetus to be a baby! It is alive, and it is killed during the abortion, but it's life is not worth that of the mother's because it isn't developed enough to suvive yet. I have conceded to many of your points; that it is alive, that it is killing. Why don't you concede to some of mine?

If it was meant for my parents to have sex, then it was meant for my mother to have an abortion. I think your .God is great, always setting his people up to sin and fail. That's why I don't believe in much of the bible. It doesn't make any sense.
|
sandyallen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Feb 2004
Posts: 4580

Posted: 11-08-05 17:08pm

Again, killing children is illegal. Abortion is legal.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12984
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 11-08-05 22:15pm

sandyallen wrote:
again, killing children is illegal. Abortion is legal.


yeah... Because a child is born and has actually lived some. A zef has not, nor does it have the right to, at under 20 weeks, if it's life is going to be detrimental to the woman. I know that sounds horrid, but that's how I view it. It has not developed into a human yet, thus it does not have the same rights as one.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12984
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 11-09-05 01:20am

jlee77 wrote:
eiri wrote:
jlee77 wrote:
eiri wrote:
jlee77 wrote:
to say your mom would'nt be here or you wouldn't be here if this, and that.....You can't say that. You may have been. That is something you can't know. Plans don't always pan out, as we all know. (the reason so many selfish b**ches kill their children).


If you were to be born, you will be. (this goes for anyone).


if my mother never had sex with my father, then it would be impossible for me to be born. Duh. I was made because she had sex with my father at a specific time, when a specific egg ovulated and a specific sperm of his met with it. You change anything at all in the past, and those things don't happen. And it's not a child yet, it hasn't been born.


Are you going to touch on anything else I said or just ignore it?


what I was saying, (*.D. U.H!!) was that it was meant to be for your parents to do the bam bam and create you. What i'm attempting to explain to you may be too difficult or ellaborate for you to understand. You like to twist words and create different meanings for them anyways and I wish not to deal with your nonsense. This conversation is over .Ms. "i'm better than everyone else".


I picture you to be an annoying troll. No offense. You make yourself out to be that way.
When your ready to hear me out and stop shutting out my explanations as you accuse me of doing, let me know. Oh...And when your ready to stop insulting my intelligence as you have come so accustomed to doing in the other threads. So much for you being that "sweet, caring and innocent" girlie you claimed to be huh?


oh yes that's right, all things are "meant to be" because we have no real free will under .God. I never claimed to be sweet and innocent... I do recall saying I was kind and caring, but that I would also call out in debate anyone I thought was being less that smart in their posts. The problem is that you are only using religion as your soapbox for this argument, whereas I am using the morals I learned from religion and scientific logic.

You accuse me of being unethical, and a proponent of killing babies, but you constanly forget the fact that I don't consider a 4 month fetus to be a baby! It is alive, and it is killed during the abortion, but it's life is not worth that of the mother's because it isn't developed enough to suvive yet. I have conceded to many of your points; that it is alive, that it is killing. Why don't you concede to some of mine?

If it was meant for my parents to have sex, then it was meant for my mother to have an abortion. I think your .God is great, always setting his people up to sin and fail. That's why I don't believe in much of the bible. It doesn't make any sense.


we have plenty of free will under .God so saying you don't is something you chose not to have under a .God you don't believe in. Kind and caring is not calling someone stupid.


i'm kind and caring to those who deserve it. I'm kind and caring to my mother, and she believes the bible. But she is also willing to at least realise that science might be right.


Quote:
i'm not sure what your definition is. And just because I do not carry your views does not make me stupid dear. Wouldn't you view that as arrogant? I think so. I am not using religion as a "soapbox".


yes you are. Everything you say is related to it. If that's not a soapbox, I don't know what is.


Quote:
we can quit speaking of religion now if you would like.


we could try... But I know he'll get brought up again and again. I don't have a problem discussing god, its when you tell me that i'm evil and unethical because of him that I get angry. God does not determine my actions, sorry. Or where was it, something about me being a sex-addict (lmao). I forget who posted that bull.

Quote:
i view abortion as wrong and evil no matter what. My morals are based partly on what I believe in with .God, and partly by what my parents raised me on. (question: you say you learned some morals from religion. I thought you didn't believe in religion??).


i don't belive in your religion, which just shows how ethnocentric you are. I belive in deism, which allows me to take morals from all religions to build an ethical base upon. Mostly, don't kill people (a zef is not a person), don't steal, don't lie, don't cheat, things like that. My moral code has gone beyond what my mommy and daddy and jesus taught me. I have taken what i've seen and learned and developed that into my own code of morals. They're based on science, upbringing, religion, and my own interpretations and experiences.


Quote:
oh wow.....Your actually doing to use the excuse that you don't believe a 4 month old fetus to be a baby your reason for not believing abortion is killing?


abortion is killing!! I've said that multiple times! The unborn, 19-week old fetus' life is not worth as much as the mother's! I have admitted this like, 2 times at least. Go look for them. At least one of those times has been during this very argument. In fact, here is the very quote I said earlier:

"it is alive, and it is killed during the abortion, but it's life is not worth that of the mother's because it isn't developed enough to suvive yet. "

Quote:
****abortion is killing!!***** an abortion terminates the baby, or to make you happy here: the "zef". It is killing no matter how you view it. So yes, you are unethical.


according to you. But there are many people who do not view abortion as unethical because we have the ability to place a value on life, which is very hard to do if the world is black and white. Like yours is.

Quote:
why do I not concede to some of yours? Because i'm not stupid and I won't "concede" to posts that tell me i'm stupid. Who would?! When you decide to be this kind person you say you are, we can talk. Until then.....Your not worth my time.


except that i'll keep callin 'em as I see 'em. You notice i'm having a perfectly nice conversation with that other religious lady?


Quote:
saying you don't believe in the bible because it does not make sense must mean you don't believe in anything that doesn't make sense. Which means you don't believe in much.


actually... There is a hell of a lot of stuff that makes sense. Math, english, science... I believe in things I can see, touch, feel, smell, hear. Things I can calculate, things I can see have been proven with logic and math. Which simply doesn't involve the bible, or ghosts, or the paranormal, or psychics.


Quote:
.God does not set us up to "sin and fail". It's called life lessons. We fail and we succeed. Everything we go through makes us stronger and it happens that way for a reason. If life were peaches and wine, we would be spoiled brats and the world would be worse off than it is now.


it could get worse than it is now? I would imagine that world to be one... Where abortion was illegal, children were forced to pray in church, and christianity was the only legal american religion.


Quote:
so in reality, .God knows exactly what he is doing with us. We are "designed" to sin, learn from sin, and strive to do better.....To better our lives.


if we are designed to sin, then we are set up to sin, or can you not see that connection? However, I can see your point on the life lessons thing... Except that I don't believe in a messiah of salvation. (oh my, I just conceded to another one of your points! When are you going to open your mind as well? It's easy to hide behind the veil of christianity.) I believe in enlightenment to a state of nirvanah. If you do bad in this life, then your soul just comes back as the next baby in line until you live a life worthy of transcending.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12984
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 11-09-05 01:23am

stillmehere wrote:
jlee77 wrote:
"poof...The baby is gone but it's okay because it's 'legal' "


it is more of a sucking sound...


x-) that's morbid...
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12984
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 11-09-05 01:28am

jlee77 wrote:
you both are delerious. To the fullest extent. Caught up in your magical world of aboriton. "poof...The baby is gone but it's okay because it's 'legal' ". Oh, how you wish!


yay, caught up in the "magical" world of proven real science, which daily proves that magic doesn't exist. Paradox anyone? Or maybe...Just maybe...

Maybe science isn't magic!! Who woulda thunk?

No, i'm sure the world is flat and the sun and the stars and the whole universe revolves around the earth, which of course doesn't explain the retrograde motion of the planets in the sky but... We'll just ignore that... And no, I don't see those moons orbiting jupiter, because that's impossible! Plus the earth is held up by a giant turtle! And columbus discovered a shorter way to india!
|
Meandering Away

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 06 Jul 2005
Posts: 535

Posted: 11-09-05 13:30pm

Quote:
the earth is held up by a giant turtle!


the great a'tuin dont forget the four great elephants.
|
sandyallen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Feb 2004
Posts: 4580

Posted: 11-09-05 15:49pm

Again, being pro-choice does not mean that I am 100% for abortion, it means that I am 100% for the pregnant female's choice, if she wants to continue on with the pregnancy, that is great, it is her choice or if she wants to terminate the pregnancy, that is her choice too.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12984
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 11-10-05 00:05am

cowboys wrote:
Quote:
the earth is held up by a giant turtle!


the great a'tuin dont forget the four great elephants.


yeah, lol. Depending on the ledgend and culture.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12984
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 11-10-05 00:06am

sandyallen wrote:
again, being pro-choice does not mean that I am 100% for abortion, it means that I am 100% for the pregnant female's choice, if she wants to continue on with the pregnancy, that is great, it is her choice or if she wants to terminate the pregnancy, that is her choice too.


beautiful!
|
Related Topics
This Forum This Category All Forums
Jump to:  
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4
New Topic   Reply



Page 4 of 4
We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.