Abortion Debate Forum - Abortion?
Medical questions     Health forums     MarketPlace     log in    

Abortion?

New Topic  This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.  Ask A Doctor - Offline
Medical Questions-> Health Forums -> Abortion Debate -> Abortion?
Medical Questions
Author Message
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 12-15-05 11:28am

sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:


tax brackets are stupid too. Just like your 20 week rule.


so you think everyone should be taxed the same amount? Then the rich are getting off easy, and the poor are hurt. That's just lovely. And yeah, what about your line, you draw it before the egg implants, but it's already alive, it's already dividing. You have your line, I have mine. You have the right to draw our line where you want, but you do not have the right to draw my line.


ideally, I wish nobody was taxed, period. Im not going to debate who should be taxed what. Yup, taxes suck but taxes are not killing anyone innocent, like abortion does. If you call what I believe in a "line" so be it. At least I am pro-life and value life, born and unborn. Amen to muah!


no you're not!! You're perfectly fine with killing it via birth control or, I bet, the morning after pill, just as long as that living, dividing cell doesn't implant!! You are the hypocrite!! You are pro-"death" just like I am. You just say it's illegal a lot sooner than I do.
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 12-15-05 17:36pm

eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:


tax brackets are stupid too. Just like your 20 week rule.


so you think everyone should be taxed the same amount? Then the rich are getting off easy, and the poor are hurt. That's just lovely. And yeah, what about your line, you draw it before the egg implants, but it's already alive, it's already dividing. You have your line, I have mine. You have the right to draw our line where you want, but you do not have the right to draw my line.


ideally, I wish nobody was taxed, period. Im not going to debate who should be taxed what. Yup, taxes suck but taxes are not killing anyone innocent, like abortion does. If you call what I believe in a "line" so be it. At least I am pro-life and value life, born and unborn. Amen to muah!


no you're not!! You're perfectly fine with killing it via birth control or, I bet, the morning after pill, just as long as that living, dividing cell doesn't implant!! You are the hypocrite!! You are pro-"death" just like I am. You just say it's illegal a lot sooner than I do.



no, your wrong. First off.....Birth control has to fail for this "issue" of the fertilizing egg not being implanted. Considering the pill has a 3% failure rate, this does not happen too often now does it? And in the rarity it does, there is not pregnancy until there is implantation and that will not ever happen on the pill. As we discussed.
And no....I do not believe in the morning after pill. I have never taken that nor ever will. I was on bc for 12 years. I got off. I became pregnancy unintentionally. I kept the pregnancy as hard as it was to grasp at first. Now I have a beyond beautiful, smart, energetic little boy who has changed my life for the best. Am I happy? You bet your buns! ;o)
|
biancatooshort07

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 06 Dec 2005
Posts: 14
Location: Desoto
Wait Another Damn Minute????
Posted: 12-16-05 10:30am

No I am not at all trying to tell anyone what to do with their body but I would like mrs. Poopoopoo to tell me what she could say to me. Because all you're even replying with is exactly what poopoopoo is caca caca caca. Yo're acting really ignorant to the fact is all we are discussing is a very important issue and if you can not deal with that then please don not reply anymore
|
Carifairy

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 12 Nov 2005
Posts: 2610
Location: Charlotte n.c.
Thanks: 12
Thanked:0

Posted: 12-16-05 12:22pm

Sunshine.. It is wonderful that you are happy! It should not be any other way. Thats kind of the point, to be happy with each persons individual choice. I am happy that I had my abortions, because if was forced to carry a pregnancy my depression would have worsened, and my autonomy violated. You are happy with your son, I am happy with my choice. I would not take my choice back for anything, and neither would you... I respect your choice, all we are asking of you is to respect our right to choose what is best for us. You do not have to respect our abortion, just our rights as individual women to choose what is best for us, and that includes keeping an unplanned pregnancy.
|
oopoopoop

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Mar 2004
Posts: 1363
Location: ,
Thanks: 58
Thanked:3
Re: Wait Another Damn Minute????
Posted: 12-16-05 12:36pm

biancatooshort07 wrote:
no I am not at all trying to tell anyone what to do with their body but I would like mrs. Poopoopoo to tell me what she could say to me. Because all you're even replying with is exactly what poopoopoo is health question health question health question. Yo're acting really ignorant to the fact is all we are discussing is a very important issue and if you can not deal with that then please don not reply anymore


i guess on her planet that means something. Lol.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 12-16-05 14:54pm

sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:


tax brackets are stupid too. Just like your 20 week rule.


so you think everyone should be taxed the same amount? Then the rich are getting off easy, and the poor are hurt. That's just lovely. And yeah, what about your line, you draw it before the egg implants, but it's already alive, it's already dividing. You have your line, I have mine. You have the right to draw our line where you want, but you do not have the right to draw my line.


ideally, I wish nobody was taxed, period. Im not going to debate who should be taxed what. Yup, taxes suck but taxes are not killing anyone innocent, like abortion does. If you call what I believe in a "line" so be it. At least I am pro-life and value life, born and unborn. Amen to muah!


no you're not!! You're perfectly fine with killing it via birth control or, I bet, the morning after pill, just as long as that living, dividing cell doesn't implant!! You are the hypocrite!! You are pro-"death" just like I am. You just say it's illegal a lot sooner than I do.



no, your wrong. First off.....Birth control has to fail for this "issue" of the fertilizing egg not being implanted. Considering the pill has a 3% failure rate, this does not happen too often now does it? And in the rarity it does, there is not pregnancy until there is implantation and that will not ever happen on the pill. As we discussed.
And no....I do not believe in the morning after pill. I have never taken that nor ever will. I was on bc for 12 years. I got off. I became pregnancy unintentionally. I kept the pregnancy as hard as it was to grasp at first. Now I have a beyond beautiful, smart, energetic little boy who has changed my life for the best. Am I happy? You bet your buns! ;o)


i never said it happened often. But can't you see that in the chances that this does happen, the egg is dividing and is alive?!? Don't you understand that fact? No, it's not "technically" a pregnancy because it has not implanted yet, but it is still alive. I know that it does not let the egg implant, duh, "sunshine", that's how it kills the fertilized, unimplanted egg. By flushing it out. Hello, ms. Pro-death. "it's okay only when I don't know i'm doing it!" gag.

Your fault for getting pregnant darlin', since you're the one who went off birth control. Don't preach how you're so superior for suffering through having the baby, you could have aborted. I hate martyrs.

I am baby free, and i'm happy too! It is possible to not procreate and still be happy!
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2604
Location: ,
Thanks: 17
Thanked:13

Posted: 12-16-05 19:52pm

carifairy wrote:
you do not have to respect our abortion, just our rights as individual women to choose what is best for us, and that includes keeping an unplanned pregnancy.


carifairy I can see how ending the life of someone else is best for you, but is your decision the best for the baby?

I have not yet met a single woman that have had an unintended pregancy that after having the baby had wished she had aborted. N.E.V.E.R.

You would think that you might had been unhappy having the child but you know maybe that child could have bringed you much happiness. He/she could have been someone important who could have made a difference in this world and you would have been very proud.
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 12-17-05 01:00am

eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
sunshine424 wrote:


tax brackets are stupid too. Just like your 20 week rule.


so you think everyone should be taxed the same amount? Then the rich are getting off easy, and the poor are hurt. That's just lovely. And yeah, what about your line, you draw it before the egg implants, but it's already alive, it's already dividing. You have your line, I have mine. You have the right to draw our line where you want, but you do not have the right to draw my line.


ideally, I wish nobody was taxed, period. Im not going to debate who should be taxed what. Yup, taxes suck but taxes are not killing anyone innocent, like abortion does. If you call what I believe in a "line" so be it. At least I am pro-life and value life, born and unborn. Amen to muah!


no you're not!! You're perfectly fine with killing it via birth control or, I bet, the morning after pill, just as long as that living, dividing cell doesn't implant!! You are the hypocrite!! You are pro-"death" just like I am. You just say it's illegal a lot sooner than I do.



no, your wrong. First off.....Birth control has to fail for this "issue" of the fertilizing egg not being implanted. Considering the pill has a 3% failure rate, this does not happen too often now does it? And in the rarity it does, there is not pregnancy until there is implantation and that will not ever happen on the pill. As we discussed.
And no....I do not believe in the morning after pill. I have never taken that nor ever will. I was on bc for 12 years. I got off. I became pregnancy unintentionally. I kept the pregnancy as hard as it was to grasp at first. Now I have a beyond beautiful, smart, energetic little boy who has changed my life for the best. Am I happy? You bet your buns! ;o)


i never said it happened often. But can't you see that in the chances that this does happen, the egg is dividing and is alive?!? Don't you understand that fact? No, it's not "technically" a pregnancy because it has not implanted yet, but it is still alive. I know that it does not let the egg implant, duh, "sunshine", that's how it kills the fertilized, unimplanted egg. By flushing it out. Hello, ms. Pro-death. "it's okay only when I don't know i'm doing it!" gag.

Your fault for getting pregnant darlin', since you're the one who went off birth control. Don't preach how you're so superior for suffering through having the baby, you could have aborted. I hate martyrs.


I am baby free, and i'm happy too! It is possible to not procreate and still be happy!


um...Did I say it wasn't my fault for getting pregnant reject? No. Are you delusional again? A martyr? Your a loon, have you been told that before? I did not suffer while I was pregnant nor while I was delivering, thank you. I think i'm normal for having the baby, not superior. That's what normal woman do when they become pregnant....Have the baby. Duh! Boyeeeeeee.......What a concept!!!!!!!!! You mean we are supposed to have those babies???? Hahahahah what a fruitcake you are eiri!
I loved every minute of feeling my sweet nicolas move inside of me and I love every minute of life with him now. I never put suffer and nicolas in the same sentence, it's just not possible. "could have had an abortion" you say. .N.Ever, never never. I'm not an evil, twisted, skanky, loser beast killing woman, as so many skanks out there are.
|
oopoopoop

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 18 Mar 2004
Posts: 1363
Location: ,
Thanks: 58
Thanked:3

Posted: 12-17-05 10:53am

nightangel73 wrote:


i have not yet met a single woman that have had an unintended pregancy that after having the baby had wished she had aborted. N.E.V.E.R.


i do. She was 17 and everyone told her she should have the baby. Well, she did. She feels her life is more or less ruined now. Sure, she loves her daughter. And she resents her every day.

But it's not socially acceptable to say that to most people. This girl knew I would not condemn her for admitting it, although most other people would.
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2604
Location: ,
Thanks: 17
Thanked:13

Posted: 12-17-05 11:51am

poopoopoo wrote:
nightangel73 wrote:


i have not yet met a single woman that have had an unintended pregancy that after having the baby had wished she had aborted. N.E.V.E.R.



i do. She was 17 and everyone told her she should have the baby. Well, she did. She feels her life is more or less ruined now. Sure, she loves her daughter. And she resents her every day.




you can't love someone and wish he/she was aborted at the same time dear. Now if she is upset for the mistake she did of having sex without protection and having to raise a child as consequence that is a different story. I could clearly see how she can resent that.
|
Carifairy

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 12 Nov 2005
Posts: 2610
Location: Charlotte n.c.
Thanks: 12
Thanked:0

Posted: 12-17-05 13:54pm

Nightangel you asked me a question, and this is my answer :)

if a woman decides to keep an unintended pregnancy, let's say for the sake of argument I did, she(i) is making a decision to be a mother. (unless of course she adopts her child to an adoptive family) if I said "okay, I am keeping my baby!", then of course I would have to make the best of it. That baby did not ask to be born, it did not knock on my ovary door and beg to be born, I chose it. If I choose to give birth and become a mother, then it is my responsibilty to do whats best for that child. It would be my responsibility to raise that child, and to make sure it is healthy and happy... But I would truly not be happy, I am childfree. I like children, but my life is great the way it is without them. Children would put a huge inconvenience on my life, and I am mature enough to admit that. Yes women who have unplanned pregnancies do not regret having the baby, because they made a concious choice to have the baby. Some women do regret having babies so young, and some women regret their abortions. Not all women regret abortions, and not all women regret having their unplanned babies. It is all about choice, and doing what is best for the woman. That is why they do not regret having a baby, because they made a choice that makes them happy. Some women do regret though. That is why women are happy after an abortion, because they made a choice that they wanted, and yes some do regret. But overall women who are allowed to think for themselves are happy with the results.
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2604
Location: ,
Thanks: 17
Thanked:13

Posted: 12-18-05 00:21am

carifairy wrote:
nightangel you asked me a question, and this is my answer :)

if a woman decides to keep an unintended pregnancy, let's say for the sake of argument I did, she(i) is making a decision to be a mother. (unless of course she adopts her child to an adoptive family) if I said "okay, I am keeping my baby!", then of course I would have to make the best of it. That baby did not ask to be born, it did not knock on my ovary door and beg to be born, I chose it. If I choose to give birth and become a mother, then it is my responsibilty to do whats best for that child. It would be my responsibility to raise that child, and to make sure it is healthy and happy... But I would truly not be happy, I am childfree. I like children, but my life is great the way it is without them. Children would put a huge inconvenience on my life, and I am mature enough to admit that. Yes women who have unplanned pregnancies do not regret having the baby, because they made a concious choice to have the baby. Some women do regret having babies so young, and some women regret their abortions. Not all women regret abortions, and not all women regret having their unplanned babies. It is all about choice, and doing what is best for the woman. That is why they do not regret having a baby, because they made a choice that makes them happy. Some women do regret though. That is why women are happy after an abortion, because they made a choice that they wanted, and yes some do regret. But overall women who are allowed to think for themselves are happy with the results.



see carifairy this is what I don't understand. If you choose to have sex you are choosing a possible pregnancy because a pregnancy is a direct consequence of sex. Same as smoking if you get a lung cancer when you choose to smoke you choose to accept to have a lung cancer. That's why the old phrase says "play with fire and you will get burned" why can't we be just responsible in making the right choices? Why do we need to approve laws that support irresponsability? For that we will have more and more girls recklessly having sex with a mindset of oh well if I am pregnant I will abort the child. How wonderful. I am sorry carifairy i'm just disturbed by irresponsability. Makes me sick.
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 12-18-05 00:27am

poopoopoo wrote:
nightangel73 wrote:


i have not yet met a single woman that have had an unintended pregancy that after having the baby had wished she had aborted. N.E.V.E.R.



i do. She was 17 and everyone told her she should have the baby. Well, she did. She feels her life is more or less ruined now. Sure, she loves her daughter. And she resents her every day.


But it's not socially acceptable to say that to most people. This girl knew I would not condemn her for admitting it, although most other people would.


she's 17. Any mature adult would not blame the child for it being born for pete's sake. What a joke to blame the baby for being born. It didn't conceive itself. :roll: at least we can give her credit for not killing it. Score a point there. :roll:
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 12-18-05 00:30am

nightangel73 wrote:
carifairy wrote:
nightangel you asked me a question, and this is my answer :)

if a woman decides to keep an unintended pregnancy, let's say for the sake of argument I did, she(i) is making a decision to be a mother. (unless of course she adopts her child to an adoptive family) if I said "okay, I am keeping my baby!", then of course I would have to make the best of it. That baby did not ask to be born, it did not knock on my ovary door and beg to be born, I chose it. If I choose to give birth and become a mother, then it is my responsibilty to do whats best for that child. It would be my responsibility to raise that child, and to make sure it is healthy and happy... But I would truly not be happy, I am childfree. I like children, but my life is great the way it is without them. Children would put a huge inconvenience on my life, and I am mature enough to admit that. Yes women who have unplanned pregnancies do not regret having the baby, because they made a concious choice to have the baby. Some women do regret having babies so young, and some women regret their abortions. Not all women regret abortions, and not all women regret having their unplanned babies. It is all about choice, and doing what is best for the woman. That is why they do not regret having a baby, because they made a choice that makes them happy. Some women do regret though. That is why women are happy after an abortion, because they made a choice that they wanted, and yes some do regret. But overall women who are allowed to think for themselves are happy with the results.



see carifairy this is what I don't understand. If you choose to have sex you are choosing a possible pregnancy because a pregnancy is a direct consequence of sex. Same as smoking if you get a lung cancer when you choose to smoke you choose to accept to have a lung cancer. That's why the old phrase says "play with fire and you will get burned" why can't we be just responsible in making the right choices? Why do we need to approve laws that support irresponsability? For that we will have more and more girls recklessly having sex with a mindset of oh well if I am pregnant I will abort the child. How wonderful. I am sorry carifairy i'm just disturbed by irresponsability. Makes me sick.


what you said is right on the money. Society always promotes irresponsibility. It's sickening. Nightangel you will find that the pro-choice here say abortion is responsible. Yup, I know, hard to grasp, isn't it?
|
sandyallen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Feb 2004
Posts: 4580

Posted: 12-18-05 00:35am

Yes, their are a lot of women that have regretted having their babies, their are a lot of women that have had their children taken away because they do not want to take care of them, their are some grandparents that are raising their grandkids because the mother does not want to. Some mothers give them to foster homes because they do not want the children.
Just because you can become pregnant does not make you a good parent.
I do agree that some women have regretted having their abortions but a lot of them feel that they were pushed into having the abortions done and are a little naive and do not realize that they had choices at the time and their are also times that the problem was before the abortion but they blame it on the abortion their are some women that feel bad and do not seek help, even though their is help before and after but they do not want to ask, we offer help without them asking.
|
Carifairy

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 12 Nov 2005
Posts: 2610
Location: Charlotte n.c.
Thanks: 12
Thanked:0

Posted: 12-18-05 03:39am

I have an iud, that is birth control. It is still not 100% though. I am responsible.
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2604
Location: ,
Thanks: 17
Thanked:13

Posted: 12-18-05 10:39am

carifairy wrote:
i have an iud, that is birth control. It is still not 100% though. I am responsible.


you are responsible using the birth control. Now be responsible to accept a pregnancy using the birth control as you know that it can happen.

I too am on birth control and I know the pills aren't 100% therefore I am prepared to have a baby.


I tell you this carifairy if you ever become pregnant using your iud please carry the baby to term and then give it to me, I will take care of the baby for you ok?
|
Carifairy

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 12 Nov 2005
Posts: 2610
Location: Charlotte n.c.
Thanks: 12
Thanked:0

Posted: 12-18-05 14:52pm

A pregnancy with an iud has an 80 % chance of miscarrying if you take the iud out. It also has over a 60% chance of miscarrying if you leave it in. It also causes septic miscarriages. If I get pregnant with this iud I will have it removed, terminate the pregnancy, and have another one put in.


Selfishness is expecting other people to live the way you want them to, without regards to their feelings, wants and needs.
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2604
Location: ,
Thanks: 17
Thanked:13

Posted: 12-18-05 15:37pm

carifairy wrote:




selfishness is expecting other people to live the way you want them to, without regards to their feelings, wants and needs.


you are absolutetly right about selfishness and that is exactly our point of us pro-lifer's. When you decide to abort you are not taking into consideration the feelings, wants and needs of the baby in your womb!!!!That baby doesn't want to be suctioned by a medical vacuum cleaner and die, the baby wants to live!! I or anyone would prefer to live in a foster home for several years intead of being killed.


Last edited by nightangel73 on 12-18-05 15:52pm; edited 1 time in total
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2604
Location: ,
Thanks: 17
Thanked:13

Posted: 12-18-05 15:48pm

And by the way carifairy out of curiousity..Why don't you get your tubes tied or have your man have a vasectomy?
|
Related Topics
This Forum This Category All Forums
Jump to:  
Goto page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7  Next
New Topic   This topic is locked: you cannot edit posts or make replies.
Medical Questions -> Health Forums -> Abortion Debate -> Abortion?



Page 4 of 7
We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.