Abortion Debate Forum - Keeping Abortion Legal
Medical questions     Health forums     Help     log in    

Keeping Abortion Legal

New Topic  Reply  Ask A Doctor - Offline
Medical Questions-> Health Forums -> Abortion Debate -> Keeping Abortion Legal
Medical Questions
Author Message
bitsy690

New User, Becoming EHEALTHy
Joined: 11 Jan 2006
Posts: 43
Location: Illinois
Keeping Abortion Legal
Posted: 01-15-06 15:57pm

It makes sense to me to have the choice of abortion. It makes sense to keep it legal. Just think of what women would do if abortion was not legal...It would be a scary sight.

Everyone makes their own choices in life. Some of those choices are mistakes and we regret them with guilt and pain. It is important to remember that the person who makes those choices also has to live with them. No woman goes to bed and thinks "i would like to have an abortion one day". Abortion is a choice that woman do not like to make... A lot of pro lifers seem to think that pro choicers like abortion or that they try to glorify it. Abortion is not nice and it isn't enjoyable to anyone...But it happens.
|
Carifairy

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 12 Nov 2005
Posts: 2610
Location: Charlotte n.c.
Thanks: 12
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-15-06 18:00pm

True... I was on birth control, and would rather have my pill work and me not get pregnant in the first place.
I think we need better birth control and condom use education for teens.
I think we also need more health centers that cater to the needs of our young teen population.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-15-06 19:26pm

I definately agree, and recent political suggestions of making birth-control education illegal in high schools really frightens me. Education is key.

The current forms of birth control also need to advance. Condoms are hopefully becoming more dependable, and as we've all seen in the last few years, there are better and better ways to control the women's cycle. Hopefully, in the next few years an even better, more dependable (and fool-proof) pill will come out. The current one is 98% effective... When taken perfectly. Unfortunately, none of us is perfect.

So that's what i'm looking forward to!
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 01-15-06 22:07pm

eiri wrote:
i definately agree, and recent political suggestions of making birth-control education illegal in high schools really frightens me. Education is key.


The current forms of birth control also need to advance. Condoms are hopefully becoming more dependable, and as we've all seen in the last few years, there are better and better ways to control the women's cycle. Hopefully, in the next few years an even better, more dependable (and fool-proof) pill will come out. The current one is 98% effective... When taken perfectly. Unfortunately, none of us is perfect.


So that's what i'm looking forward to!


not sure where you got 98% effective from. More like over 99%. It's very rare to become pregnant on the pill. More rare then you pro-choice bomb throwers make it out to be. Try again.
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York
Re: Keeping Abortion Legal
Posted: 01-15-06 22:11pm

bitsy690 wrote:
it makes sense to me to have the choice of abortion. It makes sense to keep it legal. Just think of what women would do if abortion was not legal...It would be a scary sight.

Everyone makes their own choices in life. Some of those choices are mistakes and we regret them with guilt and pain. It is important to remember that the person who makes those choices also has to live with them. No woman goes to bed and thinks "i would like to have an abortion one day". Abortion is a choice that woman do not like to make... A lot of pro lifers seem to think that pro choicers like abortion or that they try to glorify it. Abortion is not nice and it isn't enjoyable to anyone...But it happens.


so glad it all makes sense to you. Too bad your edit in your thoughts! I will tell you what woman would do. Stupid woman would probably still abort, only illegally and therefore, more dangerously. But guess what? That is not my problem, nor my stupid decision. To go and botch up your baby and you body with an illegal abortion is complete stupidity and that woman has got coming whatever comes to her. You sound like one of those nuts that blames society for everyone else. Your a classic crying example of blaming something else for individual actions. If a woman aborts illegally, it's her own stupid fault, not the judicial systems for making it illegal. I'm sorry I had to explain the obvious to you. Are we done now?


And if a woman doesn't like to choose abortion, she shouldn't. But as us pro-life all know, the needs and wants of herself outweight the life of her precious child. Why you ask? Because some woman are worthless, selfish low-lifes.
|
sunshine424

Experienced User , Rather EHEALTHy
Joined: 17 Nov 2005
Posts: 397
Location: New York

Posted: 01-15-06 22:13pm

carifairy wrote:
true... I was on birth control, and would rather have my pill work and me not get pregnant in the first place.
I think we need better birth control and condom use education for teens.

I think we also need more health centers that cater to the needs of our young teen population.


boohoo. I would have rather you have taken responsibility for your actions and not have killed your son or daughter.
I think we need smarter woman that are more concerned about others than with themselves. I think we need a legal system that punishes people who kill their children. Guess we all want huh? :roll:
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-15-06 22:26pm

sunshine424 wrote:
eiri wrote:
i definately agree, and recent political suggestions of making birth-control education illegal in high schools really frightens me. Education is key.

The current forms of birth control also need to advance. Condoms are hopefully becoming more dependable, and as we've all seen in the last few years, there are better and better ways to control the women's cycle. Hopefully, in the next few years an even better, more dependable (and fool-proof) pill will come out. The current one is 98% effective... When taken perfectly. Unfortunately, none of us is perfect.

So that's what i'm looking forward to!


not sure where you got 98% effective from. More like over 99%. It's very rare to become pregnant on the pill. More rare then you pro-choice bomb throwers make it out to be. Try again.


well, i've seen anywhere from 95% to 99% effectiveness for the pill, so i'm only going off what i've seen. I do have a question though... My pills say that I am protected during the sugar-pill week. I assume this is because the pill has prevented any ovulation from taking place, so that even if you have sperm inside of your vagina, because it is the week your period is due to start, you shouldn't get pregnant. But I know of women who, not on the pill, have become pregnant one day before their period's due date. So my question is, what are the chances after your period is over? I start sugar pills on mondays, and I don't have my period until wednesday. I never have unprotected sex before my period even though i'm on the pill because the risk is just not worth it to me. However, after a woman's period, the uterus is bare... There is no lining at all. So, even if an egg somehow ovulated in that little amount of time (which it isn't supposed to, not until day 10 I thought) then there isn't any lining for it to implant on, so even if you weren't taking the pill and had sex the two to three days after your period, your chances of pregnancy would be very low. And I am on the pill... And i've already done this once, and my period came the next month just like it always does...

I guess my point is that, even at 21 years of age, and a pill user for more than 6 months, I still don't know for sure when I am safe and not safe. People, including me, need to be more educated on this. -_-
|
Cambion

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 08 Nov 2005
Posts: 747
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-16-06 00:06am

Abortion damn well needs to be kept legal. I see far too many news articles about women neglecting, abusing, and murdering their children. These women usually have more than one child and are not exactly upper-class...So they probably couldn't afford an abortion (from what I know, they are not cheap).

Making abortion illegal would mean in increase in child abuse from women who could not legally end their pregnancies and could or would not put the child up for adoption for any number of reasons. I'll admit straight-out that I hate kids, but it's not the fault of the child for being conceived and born. I hate kids, but I also hate seeing them being hurt and killed by the people who are supposed to be showing them unconditional love and taking care of them.

Quote:
well, i've seen anywhere from 95% to 99% effectiveness for the pill, so i'm only going off what i've seen.


i have read this as well, but as we all know, each woman's body is different, especially when it comes to her reproductive health. Some women can take the pill faithfully and not screw up with it once, and they will still get pregnant. I believe the statistic is that 1 in 100 women will conceive while correctly using the pill.

Sadly, too many women depend solely on birth control as their main and only contraception, and when it fails, they wonder what went wrong. People put too much faith in contraception anymore, thinking its foolproof.

Abortion is not pleasant experiene for anyone - no woman (that I know of anyway) would go get pregnant on purpose just to have an abortion. But when birth control fails or the woman is not ready for parenthood, abortion is an open window for that woman. I have never seen fairness in making a woman keep a child against her will. It's more responsible [in my opinion] for a woman to abort an unwanted pregnancy than to keep a child she doesn't want and possibly subject an innocent child to abuse.
|
Meandering Away

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 06 Jul 2005
Posts: 535

Posted: 01-16-06 03:07am

cambion wrote:
abortion damn well needs to be kept legal. I see far too many news articles about women neglecting, abusing, and not a nice acting their children. These women usually have more than one child and are not exactly upper-class...So they probably couldn't afford an abortion (from what I know, they are not cheap).

Making abortion illegal would mean in increase in child abuse from women who could not legally end their pregnancies and could or would not put the child up for adoption for any number of reasons. I'll admit straight-out that I hate kids, but it's not the fault of the child for being conceived and born. I hate kids, but I also hate seeing them being hurt and killed by the people who are supposed to be showing them unconditional love and taking care of them.



can you prove this?.Can you prove that the abusers wanted to have an abortion.?I think this is just bs children are being abused daily and abortion is legal. In fact here you go an a passage from the future of children.


Quote:
the child protective services (cps) system, initiated in the 1960s and 1970s to receive and investigate reports of child abuse and neglect, has grown rapidly. In 1967, fewer than 10,000 reports of abuse and neglect were made to child protective services, but by the mid-1990s, more than 3 million reports were being made each year. This article examines how reports, investigations, and services are currently handled in cps, and then reviews several proposals for reforming the system.



this seems to prove that since abortion was legalized child abuse has risen not dropped.



Http://www.Futureofchil dren.Org/information3862/information_show. Htm?Doc_id=217204

pretty much an unbiased site neither pro choice nor pro life just pro child [living ]

please decapitalize.
|
Cambion

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 08 Nov 2005
Posts: 747
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-16-06 09:28am

"seems" is the key word in your closing statement, cowboys. Nowhere in that excerpt did it say anything about abortion. Perhaps the abusers did not want an abortion, but they also obviously didn't want the pregnancy.
|
Meandering Away

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 06 Jul 2005
Posts: 535

Posted: 01-16-06 10:31am

cambion wrote:
"seems" is the key word in your closing statement, cowboys. Nowhere in that excerpt did it say anything about abortion. Perhaps the abusers did not want an abortion, but they also obviously didn't want the pregnancy.




please check the date,the figures are from before it was legalized, yet now there are more children abused.Do you have proof that every one who abuses a child wanted an abortion or prove that abuse would rise, I have proven that since abortion was legal ie: 1969 child qabuse has risen whereas you claim that to make it illegal will result in more abused children yet the figures disprove what you said.
|
sandyallen

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 02 Feb 2004
Posts: 4580

Posted: 01-16-06 14:26pm

Nowadays you cannot spank your kids in public without getting in trouble and being labeled a child abuser, along with spanking them at home. Their are far too many kids telling there parents what to do!
Sex ed is taught in the schools and condoms and b/c are free for those that ask but most of the young girls say that getting pregnant will not happen to them, just like some of the older women and poof, they fall preg.
Their should always be a choice instead of having to self-abort and risking all of the after problems or going to the back-alley butcher. A friend of mine in the 60's needed an abortion and the dr's. Would not touch her because it being illegal and of all the red tape and it killed her, like it did many others, that is why it should remain a choice, that and many other reasons. No one has a right to tell someone what to do with their bodies.
Her body, her choice, whether it be continuing on with the pregnancy, aadopt or abort.
|
Cambion

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 08 Nov 2005
Posts: 747
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-16-06 16:47pm

Okay, i'll bend with my previous statement somewhat - perhaps not all women who abuse their children wanted an abortion, but they surely didn't want the child (at least, not for the right reasons).

I'll admit I don't know the definite reason why child abuse is on the rise (i guess parenthood is getting screwed up along with the rest of the world), but I reiterate - if a woman gets pregnant and doesn't want the child and doesn't want to give birth, she would have the option of abortion. If that option is made illegal, we'll be seeing foster homes packed even tighter with unwanted kids as well as more cases of women taking out their frustrations on their children because the kids are unwanted.

If abortion is made illegal, there should be a law put into action that requires people to be sterilized after having a certain number of children. We need to do something to keep the population under control. China adopted a wise policy of forced abortions if a woman conceives after already having a child. We would benefit from such a law here, but since america has "morals", and america is too good to control the population to keep it from raping the earth's disappearing resources, I don't see it happening in my lifetime.

-----------------------------------

only my opinion, but I stand by it.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-16-06 17:16pm

cowboys wrote:
cambion wrote:
"seems" is the key word in your closing statement, cowboys. Nowhere in that excerpt did it say anything about abortion. Perhaps the abusers did not want an abortion, but they also obviously didn't want the pregnancy.


please check the date,the figures are from before it was legalized, yet now there are more children abused.Do you have proof that every one who abuses a child wanted an abortion or prove that abuse would rise, I have proven that since abortion was legal ie: 1969 child qabuse has risen whereas you claim that to make it illegal will result in more abused children yet the figures disprove what you said.


did it ever occour to you that perhaps these days (sine abortion has been legalized, and along with strong actions on the feminist movement) that more cases of child abuse are being reported, thus making the rate appear to go up, when in actuality just as many abuses were happening before but no one was saying anything about it?
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-16-06 17:23pm

cambion wrote:
okay, i'll bend with my previous statement somewhat - perhaps not all women who abuse their children wanted an abortion, but they surely didn't want the child (at least, not for the right reasons).

I'll admit I don't know the definite reason why child abuse is on the rise (i guess parenthood is getting screwed up along with the rest of the world), but I reiterate - if a woman gets pregnant and doesn't want the child and doesn't want to give birth, she would have the option of abortion. If that option is made illegal, we'll be seeing foster homes packed even tighter with unwanted kids as well as more cases of women taking out their frustrations on their children because the kids are unwanted.


If abortion is made illegal, there should be a law put into action that requires people to be sterilized after having a certain number of children. We need to do something to keep the population under control. China adopted a wise policy of forced abortions if a woman conceives after already having a child. We would benefit from such a law here, but since america has "morals", and america is too good to control the population to keep it from raping the earth's disappearing resources, I don't see it happening in my lifetime.


-----------------------------------

only my opinion, but I stand by it.


well yes, but the forced abortions in china are rather cruel, and they don't care how far along the mother is in her pregnancy, even if she's just a few weeks away from giving birth!!

I don't know about mandatory sterilization either, but I do think that tubal litigations should be easier for young women to get. Hospitals don't like doing them to young women who have never given bitrth because they think the woman will change her mind later and then be pissed. Well, then she can go adopt, is my opinion. She wanted it in the first place, so she needs to either have the reversal surgery (which doesn't always work) or adopt.
|
Cambion

Active User, Really EHEALTHy
Joined: 08 Nov 2005
Posts: 747
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-16-06 20:16pm

Quote:
i don't know about mandatory sterilization either, but I do think that tubal litigations should be easier for young women to get. Hospitals don't like doing them to young women who have never given bitrth because they think the woman will change her mind later and then be pissed. Well, then she can go adopt, is my opinion. She wanted it in the first place, so she needs to either have the reversal surgery (which doesn't always work) or adopt.


this angers me off to no end that most doctors refuse to perform tubal ligations on women who have not given birth and/or are very young. A woman doesn't know her own body well enough to decide that she doesn't want children? It's amazing how a young woman who says she wants kids knows what she wants, but a young woman who wants to be sterilized is being stupid.

Yeah, reversals are expensive, but if the woman wants a biological child badly enough, she'll go that length. I agree with you, eiri - a woman can adopt if she feels a child is the missing piece in her life. We need to work on finding homes for the kids who are already here instead of bringing more into existence.

Quote:
did it ever occour to you that perhaps these days (sine abortion has been legalized, and along with strong actions on the feminist movement) that more cases of child abuse are being reported, thus making the rate appear to go up, when in actuality just as many abuses were happening before but no one was saying anything about it?


that never even crossed my mind. I keep forgetting - everything these days is about the children. If someone shoots an adult and another person shoots a child on the same day, guess what headline gets more attention? The one with the child, of course. Child abuse is most likely happening just as much as it was 20 years ago, but more people are reporting it. I mean, hell...If spanking is looked at as being child abuse, more cases of genuine abuse are being reported.

Quote:
no, there shouldn't. A woman's reproductive system is not yours or the governments. How many children a woman has is her business and hers only.


okay, i'll be gentler - how about a law that says a family can only have a certain number of children (example: 2 kids per family), and the family will be taxed for having more than 2 children. Besides having to pay for all the children need, the parents will have to pay a certain amount of money to the government. The tax wouldn't be the same dollar amount for each family...It would be a percentage out of total family income per additional child, just so there wouldn't be low-income families with a litter being forced to fork over so much money that they starve and live in poverty.

That would probably discourage the serial breeding to some extent.
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2504
Location: ,
Thanks: 14
Thanked:10

Posted: 01-16-06 20:49pm

America is very far from becoming over populated like china. America has been for a long time a country of low mortality rate and low natality rate.
|
nightangel73

Extremely EHEALTHy
Joined: 09 Nov 2005
Posts: 2504
Location: ,
Thanks: 14
Thanked:10

Posted: 01-16-06 21:02pm

eiri wrote:
I start sugar pills on mondays, and I don't have my period until wednesday. I never have unprotected sex before my period even though i'm on the pill because the risk is just not worth it to me.


so you use condoms during the sugar pill week? Reason why your period comes until wednesday is because when you take your last cycle pill then the hormones in you body drop down (since you are not taking the pills) and this is what causes your uterus to shed. It is totally safe to have sex on the sugar pill week.
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-16-06 21:13pm

cambion wrote:
Quote:
i don't know about mandatory sterilization either, but I do think that tubal litigations should be easier for young women to get. Hospitals don't like doing them to young women who have never given bitrth because they think the woman will change her mind later and then be pissed. Well, then she can go adopt, is my opinion. She wanted it in the first place, so she needs to either have the reversal surgery (which doesn't always work) or adopt.


this angers me off to no end that most doctors refuse to perform tubal ligations on women who have not given birth and/or are very young. A woman doesn't know her own body well enough to decide that she doesn't want children? It's amazing how a young woman who says she wants kids knows what she wants, but a young woman who wants to be sterilized is being stupid.

Yeah, reversals are expensive, but if the woman wants a biological child badly enough, she'll go that length. I agree with you, eiri - a woman can adopt if she feels a child is the missing piece in her life. We need to work on finding homes for the kids who are already here instead of bringing more into existence.

Quote:
did it ever occour to you that perhaps these days (sine abortion has been legalized, and along with strong actions on the feminist movement) that more cases of child abuse are being reported, thus making the rate appear to go up, when in actuality just as many abuses were happening before but no one was saying anything about it?


that never even crossed my mind. I keep forgetting - everything these days is about the children. If someone shoots an adult and another person shoots a child on the same day, guess what headline gets more attention? The one with the child, of course. Child abuse is most likely happening just as much as it was 20 years ago, but more people are reporting it. I mean, hell...If spanking is looked at as being child abuse, more cases of genuine abuse are being reported.

Quote:
no, there shouldn't. A woman's reproductive system is not yours or the governments. How many children a woman has is her business and hers only.


okay, i'll be gentler - how about a law that says a family can only have a certain number of children (example: 2 kids per family), and the family will be taxed for having more than 2 children. Besides having to pay for all the children need, the parents will have to pay a certain amount of money to the government. The tax wouldn't be the same dollar amount for each family...It would be a percentage out of total family income per additional child, just so there wouldn't be low-income families with a litter being forced to fork over so much money that they starve and live in poverty.

That would probably discourage the serial breeding to some extent.


cambion, you are like a breath of fresh air! You do make some good points... Although most american families seem to be around 3 children, so maybe that's a better limit, since america is far from over populated at the moment?
|
Tylanas

Especially EHEALTHy
Joined: 13 Jul 2005
Posts: 12985
Thanks: 3
Thanked:0

Posted: 01-16-06 21:23pm

nightangel73 wrote:
eiri wrote:
I start sugar pills on mondays, and I don't have my period until wednesday. I never have unprotected sex before my period even though i'm on the pill because the risk is just not worth it to me.


so you use condoms during the sugar pill week? Reason why your period comes until wednesday is because when you take your last cycle pill then the hormones in you body drop down (since you are not taking the pills) and this is what causes your uterus to shed. It is totally safe to have sex on the sugar pill week.


actually, we don't have sex at all, until my period is over on saturday or sunday. And then the sex is unprotected. He insists on not having sex before my period :) he's very sweet.
|
Related Topics
This Forum This Category All Forums
Jump to:  
Goto page 1, 2, 3  Next
New Topic   Reply
Medical Questions -> Health Forums -> Abortion Debate -> Keeping Abortion Legal



Page 1 of 3
We comply with the HONcode standard for trustworthy health
information:
verify here.